Результаты опроса: Сколько раз в месяц вы слушаете симфонии Брукнера?

Голосовавшие
218. Вы ещё не голосовали в этом опросе
  • Не слушаю

    55 25.23%
  • Пару раз.

    80 36.70%
  • Раз в неделю обязательно

    51 23.39%
  • Ежедневно прослушиваю все его симфонии

    32 14.68%
Страница 1 из 56 1211 ... ПоследняяПоследняя
Показано с 1 по 10 из 557

Тема: Антон Брукнер

              
  1. #1
    Постоянный участник
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Из глубины
    Сообщений
    698

    По умолчанию Антон Брукнер

    Давайте поговорим о наследии Антона Брукнера. Кто как его воспринимает, какие симфонии чем интересны, ну и конечно записи. Кто и в каких исполнения, и почему. Кстати там и редакций полно.
    Будьте счастливы!
    Zarastro.

  • #2
    РУСОФОБ(с)Predlogoff Аватар для Walter Boot Legge
    Регистрация
    27.03.2003
    Сообщений
    6,787
    Записей в дневнике
    35

    По умолчанию Re: Антон Брукнер.

    Цитата Сообщение от zarastro
    Давайте поговорим о наследии Антона Брукнера. Кто как его воспринимает, какие симфонии чем интересны, ну и конечно записи. Кто и в каких исполнения, и почему. Кстати там и редакций полно.
    когда-то в эпоху винила и застоя я познакомился с шестой. Это была пластинка из Этерновской "черной" серии. 8 25 540-541. Gewandhausorchester под управлением Хайнца Бонгарца (Heinz Bongartz). Именно эта запись послужила для меня самым сильным живым свидетельством "наивной веры" Антона Брукнера. Дирижер был и по существу остался для меня неизвестным: единственная запись с ним, котрая приходит на ум - Веллингтонова победа на той же Этерне.
    Как же приятно было много лет спустя узнать от Била Каррагана известного редактора Брукнера ( и проф. квантовой физики), с котрым свела меня "виртуальная" судьба, что он знает и высоко ценит эту запись!

  • #3

    По умолчанию

    Просто решил "отметиться", т.к. очень люблю Брукнера. Исполнения - Йохум, Рождественский.

  • #4
    Нашивки за ранения 9 + 5 Аватар для Genn
    Регистрация
    04.04.2003
    Адрес
    Москва
    Сообщений
    2,755

    По умолчанию

    С удовольствием слушал Брукнера с Челибидахе. Потом как-то принесли на прослушивание новый усилитель - послушав эти же записи я услышал так много нового, что в другом исполнении (через другой усилитель) слушать его больше не могу. Разместил заказ на такой же усилитель и жду.

  • #5
    Постоянный участник
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Из глубины
    Сообщений
    698

    По умолчанию

    С Челибидаке великолепный комплект, записанный с Мюнхенцами на EMI. Там 3-9 симфонии и месса№3. Записи с Штутгартским оркестром на DG мне понравились значительно меньше. Они несколько "стандартизированы" (насколько это вообще возможно у Чели) и качество намного хуже. Из ранних записей я очень ценю 8 и 9 с Фуртом и 4 с Кнаппертсбушем. А вот Клемпереровские записи выходившие на EMI особого впечатления не произвели. Совершенно не похожие на ЧЕли , но приэтом очеь интересные записи есть с Гюнтером Вандом, осбобенно рекомендую его полный комплект с NDR и 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 с берлинским филармониками. Как ни странно потрясающие записи Брукнера есть на NAXOS. Очень рекомендую все ранние симфонии до 4 и 8 с 9-й - Тинтнер прекрасный дирижер немецкой романтической школы, в силу обстоятельств не имевший возможности играть после войны в Европе. Очень интересна только что вышедшая 9-я с Арнонкуром и Венцами. Там к тому же очень подробная статья насчет финала 9-й, и по поводу разных ее реконструкций. Есть еще приличная запись Элияху Инбала на Teldec, но она значительно уступает и Чели и Ванду. Инбал, также как и Шолти и (намного раньше) Кнаппертсбуш делает из Брукнера последовательного Вагнерианца, не замечая влияния Баха и особенно Шуберта.
    Будьте счастливы!
    Zarastro.

  • #6
    РУСОФОБ(с)Predlogoff Аватар для Walter Boot Legge
    Регистрация
    27.03.2003
    Сообщений
    6,787
    Записей в дневнике
    35

    По умолчанию

    Цитата Сообщение от zarastro
    С Челибидаке великолепный комплект, записанный с Мюнхенцами на EMI. ........
    К почти исчерпывающему обзору нонешнего предложения необходимо добавить Скровачевского с его верными Саарбрюкенцами.... Что скажете, коллега. Да?.... "Или нет?" (С)

  • #7
    Постоянный участник Аватар для Ingrata Donna
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Москва
    Возраст
    52
    Сообщений
    638

    По умолчанию

    М-м-м... А Бруно Вальтер тут где? (Тысяча извинений, конечно, за то, что встреваю в "исчерпывающий обзор"). Из тех исполнений, что произвели на меня впечатление, я назову 9-ю с ним (это такое что-то космическое, спутники летают какие-то с позывными-кларнетами...), а также 9-ю с Джуллини и Венской филармонией 1989 (и не говорите мне, пожалуйста, что это "коммерческая" запись), там Джуллини умудрился из Брукнера сделать барокко, но не музыкальное, а архитектурное, то есть образ барочного архитектурного сооружения. И хотя мне могут попенять, что "архитектура - застывшая музыка", тем не менее Брукнер и барокко - далекие друг от друга понятия, а вот поди же...
    В записях Челибидаке (из тех, что я слышала) для меня почему-то важное достоинство (помимо всего прочего) то, что они живые. От этого получается удивительное впечатление, как у Тютчева: "О, бурь заснувших не буди - под ними хаос шевелится". Это редко удается в студийных записях, где частенько все вычищено порошком "Комет-гель". А в живых - какие-то скрыте опасности и таинственности....
    И знаете еще что? 1-ю очень неплохо дирижирует Аббадо.

  • #8
    Постоянный участник
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Из глубины
    Сообщений
    698

    По умолчанию

    Насчет Сковарчевского - скорее да, хотя он местами не Брукнера а Пендерецкого исполняет (особенно в 6-й). Что до Вальтера, то я очень ценю его запись 4-й с NBC 1940-го года. А к записям с Коламбиа оркестра отношусь более критично, хотя они безусловно весьма интересны. А вот Аббадо очень не понравился, как и Шайи впрочем. Он там самолюбованием занимается, а на Брукнера ему плевать, да и на музыку боюсь тоже. Хотя это моя личная точка зрения. Кстати Йохум очень хорош, только не Ойген, а Георг-Людвиг. У него пожалуй лучшая запись 2-й симфонии из всех которые я слышал. (1944г. ) А вот братец его, как впрочем и Караян - черезчур тевтонизируют Брукнера. А он всеже в Линце и Вене жил, а не в Бранденбурге. Кстати, насчет месс - 1-я очень интересна у Гардинера, 2-я у Риллинга, а 3-я у Челибидаке. А Рождественский с Брукнером был хорош, когда ничего другого не было, а сейчас... Да там же 5-я симфония Тищенко всюду прорывается и 12 Шостаковича.
    Из интересного что пока не слушал - 9-я с Куртом Эйхорном на Camerata.
    Будьте счастливы!
    Zarastro.

  • #9
    Постоянный участник
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Из глубины
    Сообщений
    698

    По умолчанию

    Вот нашел, тут полную дискографию Брукнеровских симфоний со всеми редакциями. Обьем большой, зато все.


    Study Symphony

    1863 One Version Only Ed. Nowak [1973]



    Ashkenazy Deutsche Symphony Orch 9/98 Ondine CD 920 ................... 43:51 - 16:05 11:51 5:21 10:23
    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn 4/90 Novalis CD 150 071-2 ......... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 5:52 --:--
    scherzo only
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 5/91 Teldec CD 9031-72300-2 .......... 46:14 - 17:21 13:03 5:22 10:11
    Teldec CD 419328
    Teldec CD 0630 14193-2
    Frieberger Orchester Extempore der Internationalen Schlaeger Musikseminare 1997
    Fabian CD 5114 .................. 40:19 - 14:23 10:03 5:01 10:52
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min. of Culture SO 1983 Chant du Monde CD 2-LDC-278.851/2. 51:28 - 19:06 15:06 6:13 11:03
    Chant du Monde LP LDX 78.851/52
    Melodiya LP C10 21615 009
    JapanBMG Melodiya CD BVCX38015/16 52:02 - 19:11 15:09 6:15 11:06
    Shapirra London Sym Orch EMI LP C-063-02-300019 .......... 46:43 - 15:50 14:16 5:41 10:38
    HMV LP ASD 2808 ................. 46:02 - 15:42 14:10 5:37 10:33
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 8/3-4/98 Naxos CD 8.554432 ......... 37:09 - 11:21 12:31 5:05 8:13
    no expostion repeats in mvts I & IV




    Symphony #1

    Original version 1866 Haas


    unrecorded




    Symphony #1

    Original version 1866 Carragan

    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch Naxos CD 8.553455
    (forthcoming, 2000)




    Symphony #1

    "Linz" 1877 Ed. Haas [1934] (no significant differences to Nowak)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abbado RIA Sym Orch Rome live 1969 Nuova Era CD 2386 ............... 45:43 - 12:09 12:18 8:19 12:57
    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic 11/20 & 12/2/69 London LP CS6706 ............. 45:40 - 11:44 12:20 8:49 12:47
    London LP 1326/38
    British Decca LP SXL 6494
    Telefunken LP 6.35256
    Decca CD 433337
    Decca CD 458 059-2
    Japanese London CD POCL 4329 .... 46:27 - 11:50 12:38 8:52 12:59
    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic live 1972 Melodiya LP C10-16751-2 ......... 47:10 - 12:20 12:30 8:30 13:50
    Asahina Japan Philharmonic 1/29/83 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) . 49:10 - 13:38 11:46 8:56 14:50
    JVC LP 9571
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 1/24/77 Osaka Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019 (full set)
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 5/15-17/94 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00246 ....... 49:31 - 12:39 12:18 9:39 14:35
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00469
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic live 11/96 Teldec CD 0630 16646-2 .......... 49:46 - 12:49 13:36 9:21 14:00
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 12/80 DG CD 435 068-2 ................. 46:58 - 12:19 12:12 9:06 13:21
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    DG LP 2560 021
    Boboc Temesvar(Timisoara)Symphony Orch 1971? Electrecord LP ECE 1274 ... 46:00 - 12:30 11:30 8:30 13:30
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 5/72 Philips LP 6500 439 & full set .. 46:29 - 12:01 13:02 8:49 12:37
    Philips CD 442 020-2 (full set)
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 1/29-30/87 Teldec CD 8.43619ZK ........... 48:05 - 13:10 12:24 8:21 14:10
    Teldec CD 419526
    Jochum, Georg RIAS Orch Berlin 2/3-4/56 Tahra CD 162 & full set ......... 43:35 - 11:32 11:14 8:11 12:20
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus Orch 11/28 & 12/1/77 RCA CD 036823 ............ 50:40 - 14:30 11:40 9:05 15:25
    Eurodisc CD 69227 full set
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
    Eurodisc LP 300 032-445
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Neumann Leipzig Gewandhaus Orch (c)1966 Teldec LP SMT1326 ............... 51:25 - 13:50 12:55 8:55 15:45
    Teldec LP 6.44318
    Decca (UK) LP SXL 20087
    Pommer Saar-Lorraine-Luxumborg Orch 10/2/93 AMU CD 091 .................. 50:04 - 13:39 12:35 8:30 15:20
    Sawallisch Bavarian State Orch 10/25-28/84 Orfeo CD 145.851 ................ 47:42 - 13:02 12:49 7:53 13:46
    Orfeo LP S 145.851
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 6/13-18/95 Arte Nova CD 59226 ......... 46:01 - 11:41 12:23 8:33 13:13
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 2/95 London/Decca CD 448 898 &full set 47:04 - 12:07 13:01 8:09 13:29
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514777X
    Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 5/87 Berlin Classics CD 116326 ....... 49:06 - 13:37 12:40 9:52 12:57




    Symphony #1

    "Linz" 1877 Ed. Nowak [1953] (no significant differences to Haas)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic live 1/96 DG CD 453415-2 .................. 48:27 - 12:16 13:45 8:40 13:46
    basically "Linz" but with some "Vienna" orchestrations added
    Andreae Vienna Symphony 1953 Amadeo AVRS 5040 ................ 43:40 - 11:44 10:39 8:18 12:43
    Amadeo 19016
    Philips LP GL 5845
    Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 10/16-19/65 DG LP 139 131 ................... 47:19 - 12:32 12:30 8:55 13:12
    DG CD 429 079-2 (full set)
    DG LP 2740136 (full set)
    Japanese DG LP MGX-7056
    DG Open Reel DGC-9131
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 12/11-15/78 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set). 46:38 - 12:18 12:31 8:58 12:51
    HMV LP ASD 3825
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 1/26-27/81 DG CD 415 985-2 ................. 50:37 - 12:54 14:20 8:54 14:29
    DG LP 2532062
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 6/86 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 03051
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture SO 1986 Melodiya CD SUCD 10-00220 ....... 52:10 - 14:02 13:10 8:49 16:09
    Japan BMG Melodiya CD CX38001/02. 52:43 - 14:07 13:14 8:49 16:12
    Sieghart Bruckner Orchestra Linz 4/11/95 Camerata CD 30CM-367 ............ 51:17 - 13:53 13:33 8:43 14:54




    Symphony #1

    "Vienna" 1891. Revision by Bruckner himself. Brosche [1980]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Chailly Berlin Radio Sym Orch 2/87 London/Decca CD 421091-2 ........ 54:14 - 13:13 13:45 9:11 18:05
    Rozhdestvensky Grand Sym Orch of Radio & TV live 12/23/83 Russian Revelation .... 47:15 - 12:19 11:32 8:14 15:10
    CD RV 10001
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture SO 1985 Melodiya LP C10 21619 009 ....... 49:39 - 12:57 13:07 8:34 15:01
    Melodiya CD SUCD 10-00221 ....... 49:39 - 12:57 13:07 8:34 15:01
    Japan BMG Melodiya CD CX38001/02. 50:15 - 13:00 13:09 8:10 15:15
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 12/11/81 BMG/RCA CD 60076-2-RG & full set. 48:15 - 12:13 11:09 9:09 15:14
    includes some aspects of Linz vers Deutsche Harmonia Mundi LP 1C065-99 937
    this issue says 7/11/81 -> EMI CDC 7 477422 & full set




    Symphony #1

    1893 edition [Doblinger] of 1891 version. Supervised by Hynais. It has
    certain changes in instrumentation, tempi, phrasing, etc.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Adler Vienna Orchestral Society 4/25-26/55 Siena Records LP S-100-1 .... 50:52 - 13:48 13:02 7:44 16:18
    aka Vienna Symphony or Unicorn UNLA 101
    Niederosterreichisches Tonkunstlerorchester Delta DEL 12010
    Summit LSU 3017
    Andreae Austria State Sym Orch (c)1951 Masterseal LP MW 40 ............. 43:07 - 11:41 11:18 6:58 12:52
    (aka Niederosterreichisches Tonkunstlerorchester)
    follows the 1893 edition except
    in the Scherzo reprise, which
    returns directly to the opening
    statement rather than playing the
    brief transition given in the
    Vienna version score.
    Zaun Staatskapelle Berlin 2/34 EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 4:14 --:--
    Scherzo only and cut Victor 78s 11726A
    HMV 78s C-2685




    Symphony "Die Nullte"

    1869 Ed. Woss, published by Universal Edition [1924]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 7/4-6/66 Philips LP 802 724 LY & full set. 43:47 - 14:27 13:01 6:33 9:46
    Philips CD 442 020-2 (full set)
    Philips LP PHS900-131
    Philips LP SAL 3206
    Leitner Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 6/11/60 Orfeo CD 269921 ................. 47:12 - 14:48 13:55 7:20 11:09
    Matacic Philharmonia Orch 1/56 Angel LP 3548B .................. --:-- - --:-- --:-- 6:45 --:--
    Scherzo only EMI CD S 68739 2
    Spruit Concert Hall Sym Orch 1951 Concert Hall LP CHS 1142 ........ 42:00 - 13:01 11:57 5:54 11:08
    (aka Netherlands Philharmonic)
    Zaun Staatskapelle Berlin 10/33 EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 4:11 --:--
    Scherzo only and cut - HMV C 2659 (78s)
    Scherzo complete the first Victor 11726 (78s)
    time through, omits a repeat
    in the Trio, then follows one
    restatement of the Scherzo
    subject directly with the Coda.
    This abridgement was to fit a single 78 rpm side.




    Symphony "Die Nullte"

    1869 Ed. Nowak [1968]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 6/5/78 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) . 41:07 - 13:14 11:40 6:24 9:49
    JVC LP 9523
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 3/79 DG LP 2531 319 .................. 45:48 - 15:12 12:43 6:49 11:04
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    DG CD 437250, 159327
    Chailly Berlin Radio Sym Orch 2/88 Decca/London CD 421-593-2 ....... 46:24 - 15:15 13:47 6:47 10:35
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514794X
    Gelmini Nuremberg Symphony (c)1975 Colosseum LP SM 558 ............. 41:18 - 13:35 10:05 7:21 10:17
    Guschlbauer Bruckner Orch Linz 7/6/81 Camerata CD 641 257 2 ........... 43:15 - 13:43 12:05 7:15 10:03
    Camerata CD 25CM257
    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn 4/90 Novalis CD 150 071-2 ......... --:-- - --:-- 14:33 --:--
    2nd movement only
    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn 7/85 Mitra LP 16180
    Scherzo only
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 1/90 Teldec CD 2292-46330-2 .......... 44:19 - 15:06 12:47 6:13 10:00
    Teldec CD 419427
    Lizzio Philharmonia Slavonica ZYX CD 4138 ..................... 43:45 - 14:46 10:59 6:47 11:11
    Maerzendorfer ORF Symphony Classical Excellence LP CE 11022. 43:44 - 14:20 11:00 7:14 11:10
    ZYX CD CLS 4333
    Marriner Stuttgart Radio Symphony (c)1993 Laserlight CD 14 091 ............ 44:50 - 15:22 12:04 7:25 9:59
    Mehta Israel Philharmonic 7/89 Sony CD 45864 ................... 41:43 - 14:47 11:11 6:38 8:50
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture SO 1983 Chant du Monde CD 2-LDC-278.851/52 44:31 - 15:07 12:47 6:52 9:45
    Melodiya LP C10 21617 004
    Chant du Monde LP LDX 78.851/52
    JapanBMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38013/14 45:02 - 15:11 12:50 6:54 9:46
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch Arte Nova CD 74321-75510
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 10/95 London/Decca CD 4521602 &full set 38:13 - 12:38 10:26 6:01 9:45
    Tintner National Sym Orch of Ireland 9/23-25/96 Naxos CD 8.554215/6 ..... 47:35 - 14:32 14:29 7:14 11:10
    Vetter organ 11/24/91 Motette CD 11651 ................ --:-- - --:-- --:-- 9:55 --:--
    Scherzo only




    Symphony #2

    1872 First concept version. Ed. Carragan
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 3/25-28/91 Camerata CD 30CM-195~6 .......... 67:22 - 19:40 10:59 15:42 20:55
    Tintner National Sym Orch of Ireland 9/16-17/96 Naxos CD 8.554006 ........ 71:22 - 20:50 10:53 18:00 21:19



    Symphony #2

    1872 Finale with the 1876 peroration. Ed. Carragan.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 3/91 Camerata CD 379-380 ............. 67:19 - 19:40 10:59 15:42 20:52
    with rehearsal ............. 46:32




    Symphony #2

    1873 First Performance version Ed. Carragan
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 3/25-28/91 Camerata CD 30CM-195~6 .......... 61:40 - 19:33 15:50 6:43 19:23




    Symphony #2

    1877 First critical edition. Ed. Haas[1938].
    This edition is primarily based on the 1877 version with some elements
    of the original 1872 version mixed in.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Adolph Philharmonia Slavonica ZYX Classics CD 4809 & 4122 ..... 50:44 - 15:16 14:16 7:58 13:00
    same as Melles/ORF below Golden Masters Series CD 500078
    Andreae Vienna Symphony live 1953 Philips LP GL5846 ............... 51:35 - 15:50 13:29 7:57 14:02
    Amadeo LP 5041
    Asahina Tokyo Metrop. Sym Orch 9/11/86 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) . 64:51 - 19:14 16:04 9:11 20:22
    JVC CD VDC-1211
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 8/25/76 Kobe Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 1/94 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00230 ....... 71:43 - 20:02 17:44 12:27 21:13
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00470
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 3/81 DG CD 429-025-2 (full set) ...... 66:17 - 19:13 17:10 10:21 19:33
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    DG LP 2560 022
    Chailly Concertgebouw Orch 10/91 Decca CD 436 154 ................ 67:29 - 19:39 18:13 9:42 19:39
    Eschenbach Houston Symphony Orch live 2/24-26/96 Koch CD KIC 3-7391-2 ...... 70:47 - 20:27 20:02 10:48 19:30
    Cantieri South German Philharmonic Point Classics CD
    pseudonym - see Lizzio and Zanotelli below
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 5/16/69 Philips LP 802 912 LY ........... 58:21 - 17:40 15:10 8:11 17:20
    no Scherzo repeats Philips CD 442 020-2 (full set)
    Philips LP full set
    Philips LP 6527183
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch live 7/9/59 Movimento Musica LP 01.032 ...... 61:36 - 17:36 16:32 10:15 16:55
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 6/88 Teldec CD 243 718-2 ............. 61:34 - 20:01 16:11 7:13 17:51
    some copies may have an editing defect that cuts out the last
    few bars of the Adagio Teldec CD 8.44144
    Teldec CD 419625
    Jochum, Georg Reichs-Bruckner Orch Linz 9/5-7/44 Urania LP 5243-2 .............. 59:42 - 17:12 17:11 9:27 15:52
    Adagio complete -> Urania LP 402
    several measures missing at end of Adagio -> Tahra CD 163 & full set ......... 59:13 - 17:00 16:47 9:22 15:44
    Adagio complete -> Dante Lys CD 476 ................ 60:25 - 17:05 17:15 9:32 16:23
    Konwitschny Berlin Radio Sym Orch 1/14/51 Berlin Classics CD 821291732 .... 64:39 - 19:34 17:49 8:59 18:17
    Eterna LP 8 20 528-529
    Lizzio Philharmonia Slavonica Pilz CD 160 159 (mono) .......... 57:16 - 17:59 14:36 6:46 17:37
    pseudonym - same as Zanotelli below Vienna Masters CD 160159
    no cuts and no scherzo repeats Pilz CD 449061-2
    Melles ORF Symphony 1977 Classical Gold CD 079 ........... 50:40 - 15:12 14:28 7:55 13:05
    takes all cuts in mvts 1,2,4 Classical Excellence LP 11003
    plus 1st repeat in Trio & Scherzo Classical Excellence Casette C-11003
    same as Adolph above
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 1/21/78 Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set) .... 65:10 - 19:50 15:20 11:25 18:35
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
    Eurodisc LP 300 032-445
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Reichert Recklinghausen Westphalian (c)1971 Turnabout LP TV34415 ............ 60:55 - 18:55 16:30 9:15 16:15
    Stein Vienna Philharmonic 11/29/73 London/Decca LP 6.35256 ......... 56:50 - 17:52 16:16 6:09 16:33
    London LP CS-6879
    London LP 1326/38
    Japanese London CD POCL 4321
    UK Decca LP SXL 6681
    London open reel E-46879
    Wakasugi Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 4/23,27/92 Arte Nova CD 74321 27770-2 . 60:33 - 19:13 16:43 7:40 16:47
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 12/5/81 BMG/RCA GD 60077 & full set ..... 58:57 - 19:07 15:42 7:33 16:05
    uses the clarinet solo at the end of Adagio EMI CD CDC 7 47743 2 & full set
    EMI Deutsche Harmonia Mundi CD 7477432
    Harmonia Mundi LP 065-99938
    Zanotelli Suddeutsche Phil Point Classics CD 267017-2 (mono) 57:18 - 18:02 14:38 6:47 17:38
    (same performance as Lizzio above) Point Classics CD 2666762 (mono)
    no cuts and no scherzo repeats, clarinet in Adagio coda
    Zender Southwest German Radio Sym Orch 1990 Amati CD 9002/1 ............. 59:23 - 17:44 16:26 8:35 16:25
    omits some of the repeats in the Scherzo




    Symphony #2

    1877 First critical edition, second printing. Ed. Nowak [1965].
    Like Haas's, this edition is primarily based on the 1877 version with some elements of the original
    1872 version mixed in. Nowak made only small contributions to it.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details



    Giulini Vienna Sym Orch 12/8-10/74 Electrola/EMI LP C063-02633 ..... 58:22 - 19:49 16:14 7:08 15:11
    pure Nowak HMV LP ASD 3146
    Japan EMI CD TOCE-3394
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 12/29/66 DG CD 429 079-2 (full set) ...... 51:49 - 17:52 13:57 6:32 13:16
    cuts a measure out of Scherzo & its reprise DG LP 139 132
    DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    DG open reel DGC-9132
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 7/13/80 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set) . 52:46 - 17:56 14:53 6:54 12:47
    cut as above Eterna LP 8 27 531
    HMV LP ASD 4081
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 12/80,1/81 DG CD 415 988-2 ................. 60:16 - 18:16 17:34 6:12 18:06
    cuts in the Finale are opened; other cuts are observed
    DG LP 2532 063
    DG casette 3302 063
    Musical Heritage Society CD 514988T
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 10/84 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 02731/32/33
    Rahbari BRTN Philharmonic Brussels 2/18/94 Discover CD 920210 ........... 58:44 - 18:27 17:04 5:50 17:11
    cuts in the Finale are opened; other cuts are observed
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1984 Melodiya LP C10-21621
    Japan BMG Melodiya CD CX38003/04. 61:38 - 18:19 16:30 8:09 18:18
    all cuts opened & restors the first Scherzo/Trio repeats
    Solti Chicago Symphony Orch 10/91 London/Decca CD 4368442 &full set 55:34 - 18:09 16:48 6:05 14:32
    all cuts opened




    Symphony #2

    1877 version Ed. Carragan [1965/1997]
    This version removes from the Nowak edition the remaining anomalies of the Haas edition.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic live 12/97 Teldec CD 3984 21485-2 .......... 62:26 - 19:07 16:35 7:31 19:13
    adds the 1892 peroration to the finale




    Symphony #2

    1892 Supervised by Hynais, with further revision by Bruckner. Pub Doblinger[1892].
    This version differs from Haas and Nowak and was until recently considered inauthentic.
    Research by William Carragan has shown, however, that the Doblinger version is in most respects
    a faithful representation of the 1877 version.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Zaun Staatskapelle Berlin 2/34 EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 4:26 --:--
    Scherzo only and cut Victor 78s 11939B
    HMV 78s C-2685



    Symphony #2

    undetermined at this time


    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn 1986 Mitra LP 16170
    Scherzo only
    Paternostro Wurttembergische Philharmonie Reutlingen Balance CD Bal-2006-1 ... 58:05 - 18:39 14:59 7:01 16:45
    live 7/26/1997 Basilika Weingarten
    Swarowsky South German Philharmonic Highland Music LP ............... 59:35 - 17:33 14:13 10:43 17:06
    Ampex cassette AMP X 56016
    Ampex open reel X-6016
    Swarowsky Munich Philharmonic SAAR Int'l Joker LP 1254 ........ 56:54 - 17:52 14:30 6:44 17:30




    Symphony #3

    1873 Original version Ed. Nowak[1977]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 9/15/82 Teldec CD 4509-91445-2 .......... 65:12 - 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
    Teldec CD 419724
    Teldec 242961
    Teldec LP 6.35642
    Norrington London Classical Players 9/95 EMI CD 5561672 .................. 57:25 - 18:48 17:14 6:24 14:57
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1988 Melodiya LP C1030748
    BMG Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 .... 72:26 - 24:32 18:49 9:14 19:29
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 8/27-28/98 Naxos CD 8.553454 ........ 77:43 - 30:34 20:37 6:47 19:22



    Symphony #3

    1874 version. Ed. Roder. unpublished
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    unrecorded




    Symphony #3

    1876 - Adagio only Ed. Nowak
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Orch 1984 Melodiya CD SUCD 10-00220 ..... --:-- - --:-- 18:14 --:-- --:--
    Melodiya LP C10-25525009
    BMG Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 .... --:-- - --:-- 18:20 --:-- --:--
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch Naxos CD 8553454
    (forthcoming, 2000)



    Symphony #3

    1877 version - 4 hand piano arrangement by Mahler(mvts 1-3)/Krzyzanowski(mvt 4)
    pub. Rattig Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Duo Trenker-Speidel 6/94 MD+G CD 330 0591-2 .............. 58:45 - 22:45 17:05 5:49 12:49




    Symphony #3

    1877 Ed. Nowak[1981] (with Scherzo coda - see notes in Oeser below)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 7/26/84 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set)
    JVC CD VDC-1047
    Haitink Vienna Philharmonic 12/88 Philips CD 422 411 .............. 61:29 - 21:21 16:58 7:30 15:40
    one extra repeat of the brass pattern at the very end of finale
    Harnoncourt Royal Concertgebouw Orch live 12/94 Teldec CD 4509-98405 ......... 54:35 - 19:29 13:26 7:02 14:37
    Rahbari BRTN Philharmonic Brussels 2/28/95 Discover CD 920319 ............ 59:11 - 21:18 16:44 7:09 14:00
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1984 Melodiya LP C10 25525009 ....... 62:41 - 21:59 17:06 7:39 15:39
    Japan BMG Melodiya CD CX38003/04. 62:43 - 21:56 17:04 7:41 15:40
    Sinopoli Staatskapelle Dresden 4/90 DG CD 431 684-2 ................. 59:11 - 21:08 16:08 7:15 14:40
    Solti Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 1993 Pioneer Classics LD PC-96-118 .. 57:31 - 21:36 15:40 6:50 13:24
    Solti Chicago Symphony Orch 11/92 London/Decca CD 440316-2&full set 59:33 - 21:49 16:39 7:00 13:57




    Symphony #3

    1879 version Ed. Oeser[1950] based on the Stichvorlage for the 1880 edition.
    This score contains a coda attached to the Scherzo, marked "not to be printed".
    Nowak retains the coda, Oeser does not.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 10/28/77 Osaka Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic live 12/95 Teldec CD 0630-13160-2 .......... 59:36 - 20:50 16:14 6:51 15:20
    adds 2 extra bars at end of Finale
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 12/80 DG CD 429-025-2 (full set) ...... 60:23 - 20:48 16:49 7:22 15:24
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    DG LP 2560 023
    Dohnanyi Cleveland Orchestra 6/1/93 London/Decca CD 443 753-2 ....... 57:38 - 20:33 15:11 6:57 14:36
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 524513K
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 10/2/63 Philips LP 900-068 .............. 56:43 - 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
    Philips LP 835-217-AY
    Philips LP full set
    Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)
    Kubelik Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 10/14/80 Sony CD 39033 ................... 57:54 - 21:15 14:40 7:15 14:44
    CBS LP IM 39033
    Ludwig (aka Rubahn) Berlin Philharmonic live 3/2-3/52 Allegro-Royale LP 1579
    first recording of Oeser
    Rubahn Berlin Philharmonic
    see Ludwig above




    Symphony #3

    1888/89 version Ed. Nowak[1959]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 10/6/93 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00210 ....... 61:34 - 22:59 16:37 7:51 13:54
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00471
    Bohm Vienna Philharmonic 9/70 London/Decca CD 503229 .......... 56:50 - 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
    London/Decca CD 425032
    London/Decca CD 448-098-2df2
    London LP CS 6717
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 3/19-20/87 EMI CD 5566892 ............... 64:35 - 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
    Celibidache South German Radio Sym Orch live 11/25/80 Exclusive CD 93T59 .... 61:35 - 23:40 17:15 7:01 13:39
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch Bells of St.Florian CD AB1 ...... 61:16 - 23:31 17:09 6:48 13:26
    same as Exclusive above
    Chailly Berlin Radio Sym Orch 5/85 London/Decca LP 417093 .......... 55:51 - 20:41 15:49 7:01 12:20
    London/Decca CD 417093-2
    Haenchen Netherlands Philharmonic (c)1991 Laserlight CD 14 002 ............ 53:49 - 22:00 14:17 6:12 11:20
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 1/8/67 DG CD 429 079-2 (full set) ...... 53:14 - 19:59 15:12 7:14 10:36
    first recording of Nowak DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    DG LP 139 133
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 1/27/77 EMI CD CZS 5 68652 2 ............ 55:13 - 20:50 15:39 7:40 11:02
    EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set)
    Eterna LP 8 27 138-139
    Electrola LP ASD 4009
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 9/21/80 DG CD 413 362-2 ................. 56:50 - 21:58 16:21 6:51 11:40
    DG LP 2532 007
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Maazel Berlin Radio Sym Orch 12/67 Concert Hall LP SMSC 2567 ....... 51:42 - 19:10 13:26 6:44 12:22
    Festival Classique LP 406
    Paternostro Wurttembergische Philharmonie Reutlingen Balance CD Bal-2007-1 ... 56:37 - 21:50 15:04 6:47 12:05
    live 7/18/1998 Basilika Weingarten
    Rozhdestvensky Large Sym Orch of Soviet Radio & TV Melodiya LP CM03579-80 ....... 54:37 - 19:49 14:58 7:46 12:04
    2/13/72 Westminster LP WGS-8327
    Russian Revelation CD 10007
    Eurodisc Melodiya LP 86 612MK
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1988 Melodiya LP C1031047 ........... 58:47 - 21:55 16:00 8:03 12:50
    BMG Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 .... 59:21 - 22:00 16:02 8:01 12:55
    Sieghart Bruckner Orchestra Linz 2/26/95 Camerata CD 285 & full set ...... 59:20 - 23:36 15:45 7:22 13:24
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 10/96 Arte Nova CD 74321 65412 2 ...... 55:20 - 18:59 15:36 7:03 14:23
    Skrowaczewski Warsaw National Philharmonic 2/81 Muza LP SX 2093 ................ 53:00 - 18:57 15:21 6:57 12:30
    Tennstedt Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 1976 Bells of St.Florian CD AB4 ..... 52:26 - 19:40 14:38 6:47 11:01
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 1/17/81 BMG/RCA CD 60078 & full set ..... 55:05 - 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
    EMI CDC 7 47744 2
    Harmonia Mundi LP 065-99 923
    Wand North German Radio Sym Orch BMG/RCA CD 09026-61374-2 ........ 53:52 - 20:55 13:10 6:44 12:43
    live 1/12-14/92 Hamburg BMG VHS




    Symphony #3

    1888/89 Thorough revision by Bruckner with Josef & Franz Schalk
    Ed. Rattig[1890] (minor differences to Nowak)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Adler Vienna Symphony Orchestra 4/9/53 Spa Records LP 30/31 ............ 53:44 - 20:55 13:04 6:40 12:47
    Andreae Vienna Symphony 1/11-13/55 Philips LP A00273L .............. 50:27 - 19:03 12:50 6:36 11:40
    Epic LP LC 3218
    Fekete Salzburg Mozarteum 1950 Concert Hall LP CHS1065 ......... 47:55 - 18:28 12:24 6:20 10:43
    Remington LP 199-138
    Qualiton LP HLPX 1047
    Goehr Netherlands Philharmonic 1954 Concert Hall LP CHS1195
    Musical Masterpiece Soc LP 2018
    Jochum Hamburg State Orch 1943 Tahra CD 382-385
    Jochum, Georg Orch of Radio Stuttgart 11/19/64 Tahra CD 164 & full set ......... 52:12 - 19:04 13:54 6:55 12:01
    Konrath Vienna Symphony 10/10/28 EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 4:19 --:--
    Scherzo only Victor 78s 11726B
    HMV C 2659
    Knappertsbusch Bavarian State Orch live 10/11/54 Music & Arts CD 257 ............ 51:06 - 18:05 12:37 7:12 13:12
    Knappertsbusch North German Radio Sym Orch live 1/15/62 Tahra TAH CD 132/135 .... 60:32 - 22:26 14:40 7:41 15:45
    Hamburg Music & Arts CD 1028
    Discocorp LP RR-496
    Knappertsbusch Munich Philharmonic 1/16/64 live Melodram CD GM40008 (set) ....... 60:01 - 22:26 14:07 7:57 15:31
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic 4/1-3/54 studio Decca Eclipse LP ECS 553 .... 53:45 - 19:06 14:04 7:21 13:14
    Palladio/Enterprise CD 4111
    London LP LL 1044
    Everest LP 3300
    Decca LP LXT 2967
    Japanese London K30Y 1030
    Sanderling Leipzig Gewandhaus 6/63 Berlin Classics CD 21512 ........ 64:02 - 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
    Electrola LP C153-28 943/44
    Schuricht Vienna Philharmonic 12/65 HMV CD 292428 ................... 54:38 - 18:51 14:30 7:19 13:42
    not 1889 Nowak as claimed on LP Seraphim LP
    HMV LP ASD 2284
    Toshiba EMI CD TOCE3404
    German EMI CD CDZ260090529242
    Preiser CD 90409
    Szell Cleveland Orch 1/28,29/66 Columbia LP MS-6897 ............. 55:13 - 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
    CBS LP 61072
    Sony CD SB2K 53519 .............. 53:44 - 20:03 15:27 5:53 12:21
    NOTE:major editing defect on older CDs,'B' section missing in Da Capo of the scherzo.
    New issues have missing section reinstated while retaining old cover art.
    A time of ~6 minutes indicates missing music - ~7 minutes for all the music.
    Previous issue on CD without editing defect but time erroneously marked as 8:18 -> CBS CD MPK 45880
    & also Japanese Sony CD 8197-8 (with Sym #

    Szell Dresden Staatskapelle live 8/2/65 Sony CD SMK 68 448 ............. 52:12 - 19:12 13:44 7:14 12:00



    Symphony #3

    undetermined at this time


    Frank Staatskapelle Weimar live 1/92 POA CD Classic 75013 ............ 57:36 - 21:38 15:11 7:19 13:24
    Kegel Leipzig Radio Sym Orch ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
    Kubelik Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 10/8/80 Bells of St.Florian CD AB16 . 57:04 - 19:59 16:02 6:52 14:11
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 10/84 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 02731/32/33
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 12/7/77 Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set) .... 58:12 - 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
    Eurodisc LP 300 032-445
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Matacic Budapest Sym Orch live 5/16/79 Sardana Records CD-144
    Matacic Vienna Sym Orch live 1982 Meteor CD-028
    Rogner Berlin Radio Sym Orch Deutsche Schallplatten CD 25TC304
    Rosbaud SW German Radio Sym Orch 12/60 Arkadia CD 772.1 ................ 54:24 - 19:39 14:51 7:38 12:16
    Sanderling Bavarian Radio Sym Orch Bells of St.Florian CD AB9 ...... 58:14 - 20:47 14:57 7:18 14:49




    Symphony #4

    1874 Original version Ed. Nowak[1975]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 9/15/82 Teldec CD 77597 ................. 68:04 - 18:53 18:42 13:11 17:18
    Teldec CD 419823
    Teldec CD 242960
    Teldec CD 8.42921
    Teldec LP 6.35642
    Gielen Southwest German Radio Sym Orch 4/94 EMI CD 60099-2 .............. 63:55 - 18:36 16:56 12:02 16:21
    Intercord CD 860.925 ............ 64:11 - 18:36 16:56 12:02 16:21
    Lopez-Cobos Cincinnati Sym Orch 2/10-11/90 Telarc CD 80244 ................ 70:28 - 20:02 20:06 11:28 18:26
    Woss Munich Philharmonic 9/20/75 Bruckner Haus Linz LP 2/12430-315.75:03 - 20:42 19:15 14:44 20:22
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Sym Orch 1987 Melodiya LP 22411 ......... 76:08 - 20:15 18:54 15:16 21:43
    MCA MLD-32115 & cassette
    Japan BMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38007/8 76:28 - 20:11 18:53 15:17 21:44
    BMG/Melodiya CD 74321-68458-2




    Symphony #4

    1878 Ed. Haas
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Harrer Leondinger Symphonie Orch live 10/19/96 Orch's own CD SW010053-2 . 60:15 - 18:06 15:28 10:45 15:25



    Symphony #4

    1878 Volksfest Finale Ed. Nowak
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Harrer Leondinger Symphonie Orch live 10/19/96 Kultur CD SW010053-2 ..... --:-- - --:-- --:-- --:-- 15:25
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Sym Orch 1987 Melodiya LP C1026301 ...... --:-- - --:-- --:-- --:-- 19:22
    Japan BMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38007/8 --:-- - --:-- --:-- --:-- 19:21
    BMG/Melodiya CD 74321-68458-2
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 8/3-4/98 Naxos CD 8.554432 .......... --:-- - --:-- --:-- --:-- 19:03



    Symphony #4

    1880 First performance version - unpublished
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    unrecorded




    Symphony #4

    1881 (aka 1878/80) Ed. Haas[1936,1944]
    Major differences from 1874 version (new scherzo and finale)
    drawn largely from Bruckner's own hand copy of the 1878/80 text.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abendroth Leipzig Radio Orch live 11/16/49 Berlin Classics CD 92772 ........ 62:48 - 16:22 16:17 10:51 19:16
    mislabeled 1951 -> Arlecchino CD ARL 107 ........... 63:40 - 16:36 16:30 10:59 19:28
    Urania LP URLP 401
    Eterna LP ET-1518
    Asahina New Japan Phil 5/13-15/92 Fontec CD FOCD 9050/52 .......... 67:02 - 18:58 15:01 11:34 20:53
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 7/29/76 Tokyo Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019 (full set)
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 2/17/89 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set)
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 7/21-23,25/93 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00191 ....... 68:15 - 19:22 15:18 12:21 21:06
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00472
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic 10/92 Teldec CD 73272 ................. 68:23 - 19:17 16:17 10:23 22:26
    Adds a cymbal crash near the beginning (4 bars after D) of the Finale.
    The cymbal crash appeared in the original printed score,
    but not in the Haas/Nowak editions.
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 11/72 DG CD 2563 252 & full set ....... 63:42 - 18:05 15:44 9:32 20:21
    DG CD 2GTA2 453100
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    DG LP 2530 336
    Blomstedt Dresden Staatskapelle 9/11/81 Denon CD 38C37-7126 ............. 66:59 - 18:23 16:30 10:51 21:06
    Denon LP OB 7382/3ND
    Blomstedt San Francisco Symphony 5/31-6/1/93 London/Decca CD 443 327-2 ..... 67:30 - 18:56 15:58 10:32 21:43
    Bohm Sachsische Staatskapelle 6/36 ZYX CD 50132 .................... 63:01 - 17:28 16:05 9:58 19:30
    Memories CD 3001
    Dutton Labs CD 5007 ............. 63:01 - 17:30 16:05 9:56 19:30
    EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... 63:25 - 17:37 16:10 10:01 19:37
    HMV Electrola 78s DB4450-4457(original release)
    Victor 78s M331
    EMI LP IC 053-28
    Dante Lys CD 052
    Da Capo LP C 053-28 924
    Magic Talent CD
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 10/16/88 EMI CD 5566902 ................. 78:28 - 21:56 17:35 11:04 27:53
    Celibidache RAI Symphony Orch live Rome 3/18/60 Concerto CD CON37 ............ 68:30 - 18:47 16:33 9:20 23:48
    Celibidache Southwest German Radio SO 11/22/66 Arkadia CD 7511 ............... 72:56 - 19:46 17:04 10:31 25:35
    Rococo LP RR2153
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch 4/19/78 Exclusive CD 92T23/24 ........... 72:56 - 19:49 17:13 10:40 25:12
    same as Arkadia above and mis-dated?
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch 11/9/73 Arlecchino CD 175 ............... 74:02 - 19:56 17:20 10:44 25:53
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch Bells of St. Florian CD AB11
    Dohnanyi Cleveland Orch 10/8&10/89 London/Decca CD 430 099 ......... 63:09 - 18:13 15:15 10:02 19:31
    Haitink Vienna Philharmonic 2/21/85 Philips CD 412 735 .............. 68:12 - 20:35 15:23 10:35 21:40
    Hollreiser Bamberg Symphony Orch (c)1961 Vox CD 8147 ..................... 63:38 - 17:05 16:23 10:45 19:11
    Vox LP SVBX 5117
    Vox LP VBX 117
    Vox Turnabout LP TV 34107S
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orch 1/16/75 Tahra CD 165 & full set ......... 65:00 - 17:56 16:07 10:12 20:29
    adds cymbal crash (see above) Tahra CD 171/174
    Jochum Hamburg Philharmonic 6/22,24/39 Dante Lys CD 007/8 .............. 63:15 - 16:56 17:14 9:34 19:24
    Dante Lys CD 102 ................ 63:19 - 16:58 17:18 9:40 19:22
    Telefunken 78's SK3032/9
    Kabasta Munich Philharmonic Orch live 6/30/43 Pilz CD 78 005 ............. 61:31 - 16:02 16:27 9:55 19:07
    Preiser CD 90304
    MUCL CD 2007/8
    Arkadia CD 78527
    LYS CD 419-424
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 9/25 & 10/16/70 EMI CD CDM7 69006 ............ 70:14 - 20:48 15:38 10:41 23:05
    EMI CD CDM 66094
    Angel Cassette AM-34735
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514289Z
    Angel LP SC-3779
    EMI Electrola LP 1C06502414
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 5/15/75 DG CD 439522-2 .................. 63:56 - 18:17 14:29 10:43 20:27
    adds cymbal crash (see above) DG CD 415277
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    DG LP 2530 674
    van Kempen Netherlands Radio Orch 1950 Telefunken LP 66026/7 ........... 59:14 - 18:04 15:00 6:04 19:51
    LP missing Scherzo Da Capo Telefunken 78s SK 3806-13
    Klemperer Vienna Symphony Orch 3/19-23/51 Vox LP 5520 ..................... 51:29 - 13:27 11:56 9:25 16:32
    Vox CD CDX2 5520
    Vox LP PL 11.200
    Turnabout LP THS 65019
    Enterprise CD 939/40
    Palladio CD 4147
    Andromeda CD 2532
    Klemperer Concertgebouw Orchestra live 12/3or4/47 Tahra CD 328 ............. 53:42 - 13:40 12:47 9:56 17:19
    the date on the cover 11/24/48 is the Radio VARA broadcast date
    Konwitschny Czech Philharmonic 1952 Supraphon LP SLPV 122-3 ......... 69:42 - 18:50 18:44 10:59 21:09
    Supraphon LP 7086
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 7/1/75 RCA CD 78952 .................... 64:40 - 18:25 14:05 11:05 21:05
    RCA CD 74321 30368-2
    Eurodisc CD 69227 full set
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
    Eurodisc LP 27913XGK
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Masur New York Philharmonic live 10/93 Teldec CD 93332 ................. 67:04 - 19:07 15:05 10:33 22:19
    Teldec CD 3984-21338-2
    Mehta Los Angeles Philharmonic 4/14/70 London/Decca LP CS 6695 ......... 64:35 - 16:55 15:45 10:55 21:00
    Belart CD 461 356-2
    Decca (Taiwan) CD 443 882-2
    Schuricht Radio Sym Orch Stuttgart 4/5/55 Archiphon CD 2.4 ................ 69:30 - 17:50 16:45 11:25 23:30
    Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 2/89 Berlin Classic CD 1161 .......... 64:37 - 18:36 15:39 10:40 19:44
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 10/16-17/96 Naxos CD 8.554128 ....... 72:56 - 21:29 16:17 12:00 23:10
    Walter Columbia Sym Orch 2/25/60 Sony CD MBK 44825 ............... 66:18 - 18:44 15:42 11:01 20:51
    Sony CD 64481
    Sony CD MK 42035
    Columbia LP M2S 622
    Columbia LP Y32981
    Columbia LP D4S 742
    Columbia LP MP39026
    Wand Berlin Philharmonic live 1/30-31 & 2/1/98 BMG CD 09026 68839-2 ... 68:40 - 19:11 16:07 11:21 22:01
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 12/10/76 BMG/RCA CD 60079 & set .......... 64:22 - 17:26 15:37 10:33 20:22
    EMI CD CDC 7 47745 2 & set
    Pro Arte LP PAL 1044
    Harmonia Mundi LP 1C 065-99 738
    Wand North German Radio Sym Orch live 6/19/90 BMG/RCA CD 60784-2-RC ... 66:14 - 18:00 15:19 10:58 21:26
    BMG/RCA CD 77706 0




    Symphony #4

    1886 (aka 1878/80) Nowak[1953]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic 10/90 DG CD 431 719 ................... 68:39 - 19:01 16:11 10:29 22:38
    Albrecht Czech Philharmonic Orch 11/24/95 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00329 ....... 64:54 - 17:57 15:34 10:30 20:36
    Andreae Vienna Symphony live 1/19/53 Orfeo CD 229901 ................. 60:15 - 16:39 15:01 9:57 18:38
    Bohm Vienna Philharmonic 11/19/73 London/Decca CD 440 259 ......... 67:41 - 20:08 15:28 11:02 21:03
    London/Decca CD 411581
    Decca CD 425036
    London/Decca CD 448-098-2df2
    London LP CSA 2240
    Decca LP 6BB 171-2
    Chailly Concertgebouw Orch 12/88 London/Decca CD 425613-2 ........ 66:14 - 18:43 15:05 10:20 21:56
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 5/12/65 Philips LP 835 385 LY ........... 63:44 - 18:18 15:51 9:46 19:49
    Philips LP 420881
    Philips LP set
    Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)
    Philips LP SPS 4-905 (80th Aniv Ed)
    Philips LP 835 326-26
    Philips LP 6599 729
    Harnoncourt Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra live 4/97 Teldec CD 0630 17126-2 ... 63:07 - 17:46 14:36 10:32 20:13
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Symphony Orch 10/55 DG CD 457081-2 ................ 64:03 - 17:31 16:41 10:24 20:25
    adds cymbal crash (see above) American Decca LP DXE-146
    Some copies of the French DG CD misattribute the orchestra as the Berlin Philharmonic
    Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 6/65 DG CD 427 200-2 ................. 64:35 - 17:36 16:41 10:02 20:04
    adds cymbal crash (see above) DG CD 439744-2
    DG CD 449718-2
    DG CD 429 079-2 (full set)
    DG LP 139 134/35
    DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 12/7/75 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set) . 65:12 - 17:48 16:40 10:02 20:22
    adds cymbal crash (see above) Seraphim CES 568527 2
    LaserLight CD 16213
    Royal Classics CD 6479
    Kempe Munich Philharmonic 12/14-15/75 & 1/20-21/76 BASF LP EB227391 .... 65:18 - 19:30 14:27 10:18 20:50
    Acanta/Pilz CD 442188-2
    Acanta LP
    mislabelled as live -> Artists/Allegro CD FED 066
    Kertesz London Sym Orch 10/25/65 London LP CS 6480 ............... 60:55 - 16:35 15:05 10:15 19:00
    UK Decca LP LXT 6227
    Kertesz London Sym Orch live 3/13/64 IMP (BBC Radio) CD 5691712 ...... 61:31 - 16:51 15:43 9:51 19:03
    Klemperer Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 4/1/66 Arkadia CD 732.1 ................ 60:58 - 16:13 14:23 11:18 19:01
    flute and oboe switching places at the beginning of the Trio
    EMI CDM5 66866 2
    Klemperer Cologne Radio Sym Orch 4/5/54 Arkadia CD 591 .................. 56:19 - 14:49 13:22 10:30 17:38
    flute and oboe switching places at the beginning of the Trio
    Frequenz CD 051-054
    Movimento Musica LP 01.052
    Klemperer Philharmonia Orch 9/26/63 EMI CD 79885 (+ other stuff) .... 60:59 - 16:06 13:55 11:44 18:59
    flute and oboe switching places at the beginning of the Trio
    EMI CDM7 69127
    Angel LP 36245
    Angel LP RL 32059
    Angel LP AE 24456
    Kubelik Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 11/21/79 Sony CD 46505 ................... 67:07 - 19:22 15:06 10:59 21:28
    CBS LP I2M 35915
    Sony Japan CD 38DC 6
    Leinsdorf Boston Symphony Orch 1/11/66 RCA LP LSC-2915 ................. 60:11 - 17:14 13:53 10:33 18:31
    Muti Berlin Philharmonic 9/7/85 EMI CD CDC 7 47352 2 ............ 69:46 - 20:05 16:03 10:41 22:54
    EMI CDR 7243 5 69795 2 8
    EMI Seraphim CD 732426
    Angel LP DS 38311
    Ormandy Philadelphia Orchestra 10/9/67 Sony CD 48160, 47653 ............ 63:14 - 17:28 15:16 10:39 19:30
    Columbia LP M31920
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1988 JapanBMG/MelodiyaCD BVCX38009/10 69:41 - 20:04 15:31 11:42 22:03
    Salonen Los Angeles Philharmonic 5/12-13/97 Sony CD SK63301 .............. 69:42 - 20:10 17:01 11:01 21:30
    Sawallisch Philadelphia Orchestra 3/93 EMI CD 5551192 .................. 66:31 - 19:29 15:54 10:33 20:35
    Sieghart Bruckner Orch Linz 10/27/94 Camerata CD 337 ................. 69:00 - 20:33 15:36 10:51 21:50
    Sinopoli Staatskapelle Dresden 9/87 DG CD 423-677-2 ................. 66:58 - 18:47 16:00 11:01 20:56
    DG Japan POCG-7057 .............. 66:47 - 18:46 15:59 11:04 20:56
    Eterna CD 3 29 216
    Skrowaczewski Halle Orchestra (c)1993 IMP CD 1059 ..................... 68:51 - 19:52 16:13 10:29 22:04
    Carlton Classics CD 670028
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 10/25-28/98 Arte Nove CD 74321 72101 2. 70:32 - 21:00 16:28 10:47 22:08
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 1/27/81 London/Decca CD 410550 &full set. 63:07 - 17:57 14:44 10:03 20:12
    flute and oboe switching places at the beginning of the Trio
    London/Decca LP LDR 71038
    Soudant Melbourne Symphony Orch Australian Broadcasting Corp
    unreleased




    Symphony #4

    1888 revised by Ferdinand Lowe. Ed. Gutmann[1889]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details



    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic 12/14-16/41 Japanese AT LP 11-12
    incomplete
    Furtwangler Vienna Philharmonic live Stuttgart 10/22/51 DG CD 427 403-2 ...... 65:51 - 17:45 18:13 10:29 19:24
    without cut in Scherzo reprise DG CD 445 415-2 [flutter]
    DG CD 415 6642 [flutter]
    Japan DG POCG 2357 & POCG 3795
    Discocorp LP RR557 [flutter]
    DG LP 8868/72
    DG LP 2740 201 .................. 65:50 - 17:40 18:25 10:25 19:20
    DG (Japan) CD POCG 9499
    DG (Japan) CD 3750
    Furtwangler Vienna Philharmonic live Munich 10/29/51 Music & Arts CD 796 ..... 61:40 - 17:07 17:31 9:55 17:07
    without cut in Scherzo reprise Priceless CD D14228
    Palette CD PAL 1074
    Virtuoso CD 69.7372
    Seven Seas CD KICC 2306
    Japanese Decca LP SLC 2334
    Decca LP ECM 685
    Decca LP (Japan) MX 9012
    Keilberth NHK Sym Orch live 5/68 Seven Seas CD 270E17 ............ 61:44 - 16:52 13:35 10:45 20:16
    Knappertsbusch Berlin Philharmonic live 9/8/44 Music & Arts CD 249 ............. 60:37 - 17:58 15:12 9:27 18:00
    broadcast recording without audience Discocorp LP IGI 383
    Grammofono CD 78563
    Preiser CD 90226
    better source than M&A 249 but fake applause added -> Music & Arts CD 1028
    Iron Needle CD 1344
    Tahra CD 320-22
    Enterprise CD SO 530013
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic studio 3/29-31/55 Andromeda CD 2502 .......... 59:38 - 17:50 14:30 10:00 17:18
    Palladio/Enterprise CD 4105
    London LP CMA 7207 (correct date?)
    Japanese King/London Super Analog LP KIJC(M) 9208/9
    London LP LL 1250-1
    Decca Eclipse LP ECS 511
    Japanese London K30Y 1029
    German Decca LP LXT 5065
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic 1960 Nuova Era CD NE 2205 ............ 69:57 - 20:19 16:59 11:28 20:59
    Memories CD HR 4468/69
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic 4/12/64 Melodram CD 40008 (set) ......... 72:11 - 21:02 17:28 11:47 21:54
    Konwitschny Vienna Symphony 1962 Eterna LP 825504/820504-5 ....... 60:46 - 16:34 14:06 10:16 19:35
    World Record Club LP CM/SCM52
    Eurodisc LP 70002/3
    Krauss Vienna Philharmonic 7/3/29 Preiser CD 90258 ................ --:-- - --:-- --:-- 8:51 --:--
    Scherzo only EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2
    Electrola LP EH 392
    Hans Pizka Edition CD HPE CD04
    HMV 78s C1789
    Matacic Philharmonia Orchestra 10/12-13 & 12/11,14/54 Angel LP 3548B ..... 64:46 - 17:05 17:46 8:42 21:13
    no cymbal crash in finale Testament CD SBT 1050
    Steinberg Pittsburgh Sym Orch 4/19/56 Capitol LP P8352 ................ 55:01 - 16:29 12:47 8:48 16:57
    large cut in mvt.2 EMI CDM 7243 5 66556 2 1
    Walter NBC Symphony Orch 2/10/40 Pearl CD 9131 ................... 58:40 - 16:32 14:31 8:25 18:41



    Symphony #4

    1888 Heavily edited, cut and reorchestrated by Gustav Mahler,
    based on the edition of 1889 by Ferdinand Lowe
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details



    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 1984 Melodiya LP C10-22411-004 ...... 49:23 - 18:50 9:16 7:48 13:29
    Japan BMG/Melodiya BVCX-38007/8 . 49:44 - 18:47 9:15 7:48 13:34
    BMG/Melodiya CD 74321-68458-2



    Symphony #4

    undetermined at this time


    Adolph Philharmonia Slavonica Pilz CD 253 ..................... 62:34 - 17:24 14:45 10:59 19:20
    pseudonym - same as Horvat below ZYX CD 4809
    adds cymbal crash (see above) Classical Gold CD 080
    ZYX CD 4123
    Pilz CD 449061-2
    Andreae Zurich Tonhalle Orch Music & Arts CD forthcoming
    Garben Berlin Philharmonic members 9/97 EMI CD 7243 55664229 ............ --:-- - 11:50 --:-- --:-- --:--
    1st mvt only in a chamber arrangement by Bauer
    Heger Berlin Festival Orch (c)1988 Maximus CD 104 .................. 67:44 - 18:08 17:27 10:47 21:22
    Heinrich Warsaw Radio Sym Orch Jubilate LP JU85184 ............. 62:58 - 18:13 15:02 10:38 18:50
    Horvat ORF Symphony (c)1973 Point CD 2671282 ................ 62:31 - 17:20 14:43 10:56 19:19
    pseudonym - same as Adolph above CMD 506 22002
    adds cymbal crash (see above) Classical Excellence LP & cassette 2-CE11040/41
    Janowski French Radio Sym Orch 6/90 Virgin CD 590142 ................ 62:41 - 18:44 15:16 10:17 18:24
    Virgin CD 7 91206
    Kegel Leipzig Radio Sym Orch ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
    Konwitschny Leipzig Gewandhaus 9/63 Eurodisc LP 201 987-250 ......... 60:46 - 16:22 14:25 10:23 19:36
    Eurodisc LP 86 367 XHK
    Denon CD COCO 75407
    Kreutzer Royal Danish Orchestra Landscape CD 10285
    Kubelik Vienna Philharmonic live 1971 Unitel 35mm
    Kubelik Bavarain Radio Sym Orch live Bells of St. Florian CD AB12 .... 60:34 - 17:02 14:28 9:52 19:12
    Macal Halle Orchestra 4/84 Classics for Pleasure LP 414471 . 66:54 - 19:28 16:39 10:04 20:43
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 11/82 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 02254/55
    Mora Munich Youth Orch 4/18/93 Lotus Classics CD 9311 ...........72:51 - 20:20 16:31 11:15 24:45
    Neuhold Royal Flanders Philharmonic 7/8/88 Naxos CD 8.550154 ............. 67:16 - 18:32 16:11 10:41 21:52
    van Otterloo Hague Residentie 5/6-7/53 Philips LP A00658-98 ............ 64:01 - 17:49 16:16 10:11 19:30
    Epic LP SC 6001
    Rogner RSO Berlin (East) 7/83,1/84 Berlin Classics CD 306328 ....... 58:21 - 15:16 13:36 10:53 18:28
    Deutsche Schallplatten Japan CD 22TC278
    Sanderling Bavarian Radio Sym Orch Bells of St.Florian CD AB10 ..... 68:48 - 19:21 17:09 10:49 22:04
    Schmidt-Isserstedt North German Radio Sym Orch 12/14,16/66 Tahra CD 9901/2
    Schmidt-Isserstedt North German Radio Sym Orch 3/3/61 CinCin CD 1033 ............ 65:49 - 18:28 16:06 10:42 20:32
    Schmogner at the organ of La Madelaine, Paris 4/94 Lade CD ELCD 009 ......... 68:54 - 19:27 16:22 11:22 21:23
    Version for organ by Thomas Schmogner
    Stein Bamberg Sym Orch 10/87 RCA Eurodisc CD 257873 .......... 64:08 - 18:02 14:52 10:59 20:13
    BMG CD CML027 ................... 64:08 - 17:57 14:47 10:55 20:10
    Tchakarov Leningrad Philharmonic Sym Orch (c)1978 Melodiya LP C10 09477-80 ... 63:36 - 18:50 14:18 10:00 20:28
    Tennstedt Berlin Philharmonic 12/16/81 EMI CD 389523 ................... 70:28 - 20:37 17:04 10:12 22:22
    Angel LP DSB-3935
    EMI Toshiba CC38-3124
    Tennstedt L
    Будьте счастливы!
    Zarastro.

  • #10
    Постоянный участник
    Регистрация
    12.07.2003
    Адрес
    Из глубины
    Сообщений
    698

    По умолчанию

    Tennstedt London Philharmonic live Halloo CD 03/4
    Tubbs Hastings Symphony 1954 Allegro Elite LP 3106-7 ......... 63:04 - 17:51 14:24 10:48 19:46
    Uno Shinsei Nihon Sym Orch 1/86 Art Union LP 3009
    Vonk Residenzorchester der Haag VAN CD
    Wallberg Vienna National Orch 5/60 Concert Hall LP SMSC 2489 ....... 64:23 - 17:17 16:38 10:44 19:44
    (Vienna Sym Orch) Guilde Internationale LP SMS2489. 63:48 - 17:10 16:16 10:40 19:27
    Festival Classique LP CFC 60015
    Watanabe Japan Philharmonic Sym Orch Canyon Classics CD PCCL118
    Weller Basel Sym Orch live 9/22/94 Ars Musici CD 1120 .............. 64:50 - 19:12 14:44 10:12 20:24
    Zsoltay Suddeutsch Philharmonie, Stuttgart (c)1975 Saphir LP 25796 ......... 63:14 - 18:41 14:10 10:00 20:24
    Intercord CD 820717 ............. 63:27 - 18:41 14:06 10:01 20:23
    Mace LP 3609




    Symphony #5

    1876 version - unpublished
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    unrecorded




    Symphony #5

    1878 Ed. Haas [1935](no significant differences to Nowak)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abendroth Leipzig Radio Sym Orch 5/27/49 Arlecchino CD 149 ............... 76:11 - 22:07 17:14 13:29 23:21
    Berlin Classics CD 92802
    Eterna LP ET 1915-20
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 1/25/78 Osaka Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
    Bohm Sachsische Staatskapelle 1937 ZYX CD 5014 ..................... 69:10 - 19:25 15:09 13:08 21:28
    EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 ........... 70:17 - 19:44 15:28 13:20 21:47
    Electrola (original release)
    Discocorp LP RR-452
    Victor 78s M770-771
    Dante Lys CD 059
    Iron Needle CD 1369
    Grammofono CD AB 78812/13
    Recital Records LP RR452 (Bruno Walter Soc.)
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic live 10/25-28/42 DG CD 427 774-2 ............. 68:36 - 19:08 15:29 12:00 21:58
    Berlin DG CD 449 349-2
    Music & Arts CD 538
    Nippon Columbia CD 35C37 7297
    Bella Musica BMF 967
    DG CD 427 7732
    DG CD 3750
    DG (Japan) CD POCG 9479
    Melodiya CD MEL 10 00714
    Dante Lys CD 108
    Iron Needle CD 1378
    French Furt. Soc. LP SWF 8203-4
    Arkadia CD 78534
    Russian Compact Disc RUJ25005
    Melodiya LP M10 42555-42558
    Discocorp LP RR 538
    French Furtwangler Society LP SWF 8203-8204
    Nippon Columbia LP OZ 7600
    Furtwangler Vienna Philharmonic live 8/19/51 EMI CD 565750 2 ................. 70:12 - 19:48 14:47 12:22 22:43
    Arkadia CD 3601
    Seven Seas CD KICC 2116 ......... 69:53 - 19:34 14:49 12:21 23:09
    Discocorp LP RR-314
    Fonit Cetra LP FE-42
    Recital Records LP RR508 (Bruno Walter Soc.)
    Rococo LP 2034
    German Furtwangler Society LP F667.497-F667.498M
    Virtuoso CD 269.7342
    Horenstein BBC Symphony Orch live 9/15/71 Music & Arts CD 697 ............. 73:12 - 18:47 15:57 13:46 24:13
    Royal Albert Hall, London Phoenix CD 703.1
    Descant CD 03 ................... 73:18 - 18:48 15:56 13:49 24:04
    Intaglio CD 7541 ................ 72:37 - 18:48 15:56 13:49 24:04
    BBC Legends CD BBCL 40332
    Jochum Hamburg Philharmonic 6/3-4/38 Capitol Telefunken LP P-8049/50 . 79:01 - 21:20 21:20 12:02 24:02
    Telefunken 78's E2672/80
    Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 1949/50 DG LP spurious
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 1949/50 DG LP spurious
    (recording made with 2 orchestras after the founding of the BRSO
    to show how high a level the orchestra had reached in just a few months)
    Jochum, Georg Bruckner Orch Linz 5/25/44 Tahra CD 166 & full set ......... 76:33 - 21:18 17:42 13:53 22:55
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 11/29-12/3/76 Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set) .... 78:30 - 21:10 17:10 14:18 25:52
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 (full set)
    Eurodisc LP 25413XFK
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set




    Symphony #5

    1878 Ed. Nowak [1952] or Haas [1935] (no significant differences)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic live 10/93 DG CD 445879-2 .................. 71:50 - 19:33 16:33 12:14 23:30
    Albert Bavarian State Youth Orch 10/82 Calig LP 30838/9 ................ 75:45 - 20:15 18:10 12:45 24:35
    Asahina New Japan Phil live 9/2/92 Fontec CD FOCD 9050/52 .......... 79:43 - 22:45 17:22 14:04 24:42
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 6/27/94 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00261 ....... 80:53 - 22:50 18:51 13:57 24:59
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00473
    Asahina Tokyo Metrop. Sym Orch live 9/3/80 JVC CD VICC 40190-99(full set)
    Asahina Tokyo Sym Orch 4/12/95 Pony Canyon CD 362 .............. 80:22 - 23:21 17:26 13:19 26:02
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic 11/8/91 Teldec CD 9031-73271-2 .......... 71:47 - 20:13 16:20 12:15 22:59
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 12/13/77 DG LP 2707 113 .................. 75:39 - 21:25 17:18 13:17 23:39
    DG CD full set
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    van Beinum Concertgebouw Orchestra 3/9,11-12/59 Philips LP 6768 023 ......... 71:43 - 19:50 15:25 14:33 21:55
    CD published by the
    Concertgebouw Orch with book
    ISBN 90-6808-170-2
    Philips LP 6768023
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 2/14,16/93 EMI CD 556691 2 .............. 87:40 - 22:43 24:14 14:33 26:10
    date? -> Audior CD 523/4 ................. 84:05 - 21:55 22:44 13:56 25:16
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch 11/26/81 Exclusive CD 92T44/46 .......... 83:16 - 21:38 23:07 13:35 24:56
    Chailly Royal Concertgebouw Orch 6/91 Decca/London CD 433 819 ......... 75:29 - 20:24 18:07 13:07 23:31
    Dohnanyi Cleveland Orch 1/20-21/91 London/Decca CD 433-318-2 ....... 73:59 - 19:41 18:10 13:05 22:53
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514383W
    Eichhorn Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 10/4-5/90 Capriccio CD 10609 ............. 79:16 - 21:09 17:34 14:22 26:11
    2nd mvt only -> LaserLight CD 14 091 ............ --:-- - --:-- 17:34 --:-- --:--
    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 7/3/93 Camerata CD 335/6 ............... 80:55 - 20:43 17:38 14:41 27:39
    Gielen Southwest German Radio Sym Orch 11&12/89 Intercord CD 860.907 .... 70:00 - 19:00 18:05 12:15 20:40
    Intercord CD 830.872
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 12/71 Philips LP 6700 055 & full set .. 72:33 - 18:52 18:33 12:17 22:51
    Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)
    Haitink Vienna Philharmonic 3/88 Philips CD 422 342 .............. 76:59 - 21:10 16:47 13:36 25:26
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 10/87 Teldec CD 35785 ................. 70:41 - 19:43 14:41 13:45 22:22
    Teldec CD 419922
    Teldec CD 242426
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 2/8-15/58 DG CD 429 079-2 (full set) ..... 76:52 - 20:48 19:18 12:30 23:59
    DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    DG LP SA 7300
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orchestra 5/30-31/64 Philips CD 426 107-2 .......... 75:54 - 20:54 18:55 12:41 23:04
    live Bendictine Monastery, Ottobeuren Belart CD 461 326-2
    Philips LP PHS2 991
    Philips LP 835 225/26 AY
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orchestra Tahra CD 247 .................... 82:35 - 22:13 20:48 13:54 25:40
    from 2 live performances 12/4/86
    Jochum's last concert in Amsterdam
    Jochum French National Orch live 10/22/69 Disques Montaigne CD 8770 ..... 74:58 - 20:17 18:36 12:44 23:09
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 3/3/80 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set) . 77:30 - 21:26 19:16 13:04 23:42
    EMI CD CZS5 72661-2
    Angel LP EAC-87066/67
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 12/11/76 DG CD 415 985-2 ................. 80:48 - 20:42 21:34 13:44 24:48
    DG LP 2707 101
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Karajan Vienna Philharmonic live 8/27/69 Salzburg Arkadia CD 720 ......... 77:27 - 20:20 18:38 13:21 25:09
    Hunt CD 720
    Karajan Vienna Symphony Orch live 10/2/54 Orfeo CD 226905 (5 CD set) ..... 79:57 - 21:13 18:39 12:53 26:34
    Orfeo CD 231901
    Kegel Leipzig Radio Sym Orch ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
    Kempe Munich Philharmonic Orch live 5/25-27/75 BASF LP 39 22526-7 ...... 74:50 - 20:53 17:10 12:37 24:10
    Acanta LP HA22526
    Acanta/Pilz CD 442188-2
    Odyssey LP Y2 35243
    Klemperer New Philharmonia 3/67 EMI CD 63612 .................... 79:29 - 21:20 16:37 14:44 26:46
    Angel 36444
    Angel LP SB 3709
    Klemperer Vienna Philharmonic live 6/2/68 Arkadia CD 569 .................. 76:17 - 21:06 15:07 14:22 25:22
    Topazio CD 260411
    Music & Arts CD 836
    Seven Seas CD 2078
    Konwitschny Leipzig Gewandhaus Orch 6/30/61 Berlin Classics CD 2079-2 ....... 81:17 - 21:41 18:59 14:06 26:22
    Eurodisc LP 86 367 XHK
    Maazel Vienna Philharmonic 3/28/74 London 2238 ..................... 75:27 - 20:26 18:04 12:31 24:26
    London LP 1326/38
    Telefunken-Decca LP 6.35256
    Decca LP SXL 6686-7
    Japanese London CD POCL 4324 .... 75:57 - 20:29 18:07 12:33 24:29
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch Electrecord LP
    Vanguard LP VSD 71239/40
    Matacic Czech Philharmonic (c)1972 Supraphon LP SM 1211-2 .......... 70:03 - 19:25 18:18 11:50 20:30
    mixture of original version + Supraphon CD 7418
    some Schalk cuts in slow mvt & Finale Denon CD COCO 7372
    Matacic French National Orch 5/21/79 Sardana Records CD-145/6
    Ormandy Philadelpia Orch 4/13/65 Sony CD MB2K 45669 & 48160 ...... 72:38 - 20:02 16:50 12:29 23:00
    Columbia LP M2L 368
    Pfluger Leipzig Philharmonic 4/3-4/52 Urania LP URLP239 ............... 73:15 - 20:09 15:36 13:28 24:02
    (aka Leipzig Radio Sym Orch) Lys CD 417 ...................... 74:27 - 20:29 15:52 13:44 24:22
    Saga LP
    Rahbari BRTN Philharmonic Brussels 2/96 Koch Discover CD DICD920430 ..... 77:02 - 18:43 21:27 13:55 22:36
    Rogner RSO Berlin (East) 9/83 & 1/84 Berlin Classics CD 301125 ....... 68:26 - 19:40 14:41 13:48 20:02
    Eterna CD BC3011-2
    Rosbaud Southwest German Radio Sym 1960 Arkadia CD 746.1 ................ 75:53 - 20:11 16:51 14:49 24:02
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture Sym Orch 2/24/84 Russian Revelation CD 10053 . 73:10 - 20:17 15:16 14:52 22:40
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Sym Orch 7/84 Icone CD ICN9430-2 ........ 78:06 - 21:12 17:27 16:13 23:14
    Melodiya LP C10-22055-007 ....... 77:45 - 21:06 17:21 16:10 23:08
    Japan BMG/Melodiya BVCX-38009/10 .78:02 - 21:05 17:20 16:06 23:07
    Sawallisch Bavarian State Orch 3/20/91 Orfeo CD 241.911 ................ 76:22 - 21:28 16:58 12:44 25:12
    Scholz Suddeutsche Philharmonie DeAgostini 61 ................... 72:50 - 19:24 18:10 12:29 22:40
    Orbis CD CCC077
    Schuricht Hessischen Radio Sym Orch 2/27/59 ?
    Schuricht Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch live 10/18/62 Arkadia CD 742.1 .......... 73:06 - 20:57 16:07 9:08 26:54
    Hunt CD 742
    Schuricht Vienna Philharmonic live 2/24/63 Musica Classica CD 2001/2 ....... 76:05 - 21:32 17:18 12:12 24:59
    Stradivarius CD 2001/2
    fake stereo -> Memories CD HR4582 ............. 77:33 - 21:58 17:36 12:33 25:26
    DG 435332
    pure mono -> DG CD 435321-2
    Sieghart Linz Bruckner Orch 10/95 St.Florian CD BOL 1095 .................. 80:26 - 21:00 18:57 14:34 25:40
    exclusive issue 1996 Centenary Exhibition, St.Florian
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 5/31 - 6/3/96 Arte Nova CD 43305 2 .... 73:23 - 19:45 16:19 13:10 24:01
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 1/80 London/Decca CD set ............. 79:27 - 20:27 21:27 13:25 23:48
    London LDR 10031
    London/Decca CD 425 008-2
    Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 1/90 Berlin Classic CD 1162 .......... 69:33 - 18:44 13:55 14:13 22:42
    Swarowsky South German Philharmonic Highland Music LP
    see Weiss below Preservation Music LP PM7010 .... 72:55
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 4/19-20/96 Naxos CD 8553452 ......... 76:46 - 20:17 16:23 14:17 25:55
    Wallberg Vienna National Orch 5/66 Festivale Classique LP 60015-2 .. 71:13 - 20:49 17:16 12:21 20:47
    (aka Vienna Sym Orch)
    Finale cut from L-Q (vi/de in both Haas & Nowak)
    Wand Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 1986 Halloo CD HAL-17/18
    Wand Berlin Philharmonic live 1/12-14/96 BMG CD 09026-68503-2 ......... 77:14 - 21:31 16:26 14:20 24:57
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 7/7/74 BMG/RCA CD 60080 & full set ..... 74:20 - 20:10 15:49 14:13 24:08
    EMI CD CDC 7 47746 2 & full set
    Pro Arte LP 2PAL-2008
    Harmonia Mundi LP 153-99 670-71
    Wand NDR-Sinfonieorchester live 10/8-10/89 Hamburg RCA CD 09026680472 . 73:29 - 20:27 15:43 13:45 23:39
    RCA BMG CD 60361
    Weiss Phil Vereinigung Wien Tuxedo CD 1094/5 ................ 72:37 - 19:24 18:06 12:22 23:24
    same as Swarowsky above
    Welser-Most London Philharmonic live 5,6/1/93 EMI CD 5 55125 2 ............... 70:25 - 19:04 15:59 13:49 21:31



    Symphony #5

    1880s version - unpublished Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    unrecorded




    Symphony #5

    1894 revision by Schalk Ed. Doblinger[1896]
    Huge cuts, particularly in Finale, comprehensive reorchestration,
    and major changes in dynamics, phrasing and expressive markings.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Botstein London Philharmonic 1/98 Telarc CD 80509 ................. 56:53 - 16:24 14:41 8:31 16:51
    Walthamstow Hall
    Dauber Dol Dauber's Salon Orch pre-1936 Electrola HMV 78s AN189
    scherzo only
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic studio 6/3-6/56 Andromeda CD 2517 ............ 60:16 - 18:46 13:19 9:31 18:42
    London/Decca CD 448 581-2
    Palladio CD 4114
    London LP LL1527/8
    London Stereo Treasury STS 15121/2
    Knappertsbusch Munich Philharmonic live 3/19/59 Frequenz CD 051-038 ............. 64:14 - 19:31 14:21 11:02 19:20
    Movimento Musica LP 02.008
    Melodram CD 40008 (full set)
    Music & Arts CD 1028
    Noguchi Furtwangler Institute Phil Orch Tokyo CD WCD115 .................. 63:52 - 20:39 14:13 10:07 18:53
    live 1996




    Symphony #6

    1881 Original version Ed. Haas[1935]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Andreae Zurich Tonhalle Orch Music & Arts CD forthcoming
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 9/1/77 Tokyo Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
    Bongartz Leipzig Gewandhaus Orch 12/64 Philips LP PHC 9048 ............. 58:31 - 17:25 18:10 8:24 14:32
    Berlin Classics 9167-2
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 11/29/91 EMI CD 5566942 ................. 62:29 - 17:02 22:01 8:18 15:08
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic live 11/13-16/43 Music & Arts CD 805 ......... --:-- - --:-- 16:13 7:37 12:06
    last 3 movements only Tahra CD FURT 1004-1007
    Melodiya CD MEL 10 00720
    LYS CD 106-107
    Melodiya LP M10 47465 005
    French Furt Soc LP SWF 8801/2/3
    EMI CD CHS5 66210-2
    Iron Needle CD 1380
    Akira Tanaka CD 11/12
    Russian Compact Disc 25011
    Japan LP W 28-29
    French Furtwangler Society CD SWF 963
    Jochum, Georg Bruckner Orch Linz live 6/26/44 Urania LP URLP 7041
    opening of finale missing some measures Dante Lys CD 477 ................ 51:50 - 14:00 17:27 8:12 12:11
    Classics Club LP x141
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 12/70 Philips LP 6500 164 & full set .. 53:59 - 15:16 17:25 7:51 13:27
    Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 9/26/79 DG CD 447 525-2 ................. 57:36 - 15:16 18:58 7:52 15:13
    DG CD 419194
    DG LP 2531 295
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Klemperer Concertgebouw Orch live 6/22/61 Music & Arts CD 247 ............. 54:03 - 17:27 12:40 8:36 15:20
    Movimento Musica LP o1.056
    Sterling CD 1056
    Klemperer New Philharmonia 3/21/67 Arkadia CD 725 .................. 55:08 - 16:58 14:45 9:24 14:01
    Hunt CD 725
    according to Mark Kluge this is a distorted mono pirate
    of the EMI with wrong date & fake applause
    Klemperer New Philharmonia studio 11/64 EMI CD 763351-2 ................. 54:54 - 17:02 14:42 9:23 13:48
    Angel LP 36271
    EMI CD 3CDM5 67037-2
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 9/10-14/78 Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set) .... 53:20 - 14:43 15:00 8:29 15:08
    Eurodisc LP 300639440
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Stein Vienna Philharmonic 11/15/72 London/Decca LP CS-6880 ......... 54:15 - 16:34 16:03 8:02 13:36
    London/Decca LP 1326/38
    Decca LP SXL 6682
    Telefunken-Decca LP 6.35256
    Japanese London CD POCL 4322 .... 54:41 - 16:42 16:10 8:06 13:43
    Swoboda Vienna Symphony Orch 1950 Westminster LP WL 5055-6 ........ 60:02 - 15:01 21:08 10:01 13:52
    Westminster LP XWN 18074
    Westminster LP W 9700
    Tintner Bohuslav Martinu Phil 9/2-5/92 Deutsche SchallplattenCD DS1005-2 55:31 - 16:35 16:51 8:20 13:45
    Tintner New Zealand Sym Orch 7/31-8/2/95 Naxos CD 8.553453 ............... 59:47 - 17:02 18:46 8:55 14:44
    Wand NDR-Sinfonieorchester 12/4-5/88 Hamburg RCA CD RD 60061-2 ...... 54:17 - 16:06 15:47 8:57 13:27
    Wand NDR-Sinfonieorchester 5/15/95 Hamburg RCA CD 09026 68452 2 .... 55:07 - 16:37 15:57 8:50 13:41




    Symphony #6

    1881 Original version Ed. Nowak[1952] (no significant differences to Haas)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 4/1-4/94 Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00318 ....... 59:19 - 16:01 19:11 9:11 14:38
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00474
    Asahina Tokyo Symphony Orch live 1/28/84 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set)
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic live 5/94 Teldec CD 94556 ..................54:46 - 15:48 17:05 8:27 13:27
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 12/13/77 DG LP 2531 043 .................. 58:08 - 16:35 18:13 8:48 14:32
    Lovallo discography gives above date DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    this issue says 12/78 -> DG CD full set
    Blomstedt San Francisco Symphony 10/8/90 London/Decca CD 436 129-2 ....... 57:44 - 16:36 18:49 8:15 14:04
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic 11/26-30/91 Sony VHS SHV 48348 .............. 65:49 - 18:20 23:09 8:43 15:37
    Sony Laserdisc SLV48348
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic Artists CD FED 63 ............... 60:22 - 16:56 20:34 8:05 14:42
    Cantieri South German Philharmonic (c)1992 Point CD 2650062 ................ 50:58 - 13:09 15:39 8:05 13:55
    actually Hans Swarowsky
    Chailly Royal Concertgebouw Orch 2/17-19/97 London/Decca CD 289458 189-2 . 57:30 - 17.05 16.44 8.58 14.27
    Dohnanyi Cleveland Orch 10/7/91 London/Decca CD 436 153-2 ....... 55:17 - 15:17 16:57 8:28 14:35
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514680F
    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 3/31/94 Camerata CD 345 ................. 60:43 - 16:52 18:14 9:09 16:15
    Eschenbach Schleswig-Holstein Fest 7/88 Eurodisc CD RG69010 ............. 59:20 - 16:14 19:08 8:37 15:21
    Gelmetti Frankfurt Radio Sym Orch 1997 Denon DVD
    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn 4/90 Novalis CD 150 071-2 .......... --:-- - --:-- 17:21 --:-- --:--
    2nd movement only
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 9/88 Teldec CD 4509-99691-2 .......... 58:56 - 17:51 17:03 8:32 15:02
    Teldec CD 420027
    Teldec CD 244182
    Janowski Orch Phil de Radio France live Chant du Monde CD CMX 378-081/4
    Jochum Bavarian Radio Sym Orch 7/3/66 DG CD 429 079-2 (full set) ...... 55:05 - 16:31 17:08 7:55 13:20
    DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    DG LP 139136
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orch live 11/2/80 Tahra CD 167 & full set ......... 58:34 - 17:35 18:49 8:02 13:45
    bars 332-357 cut in finale Tahra CD 171/174
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 6/13/78 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set) . 56:23 - 16:11 18:36 7:58 13:35
    EMI CD CZS5 72661-2
    Eterna LP 8 27 535
    Angel LP SZ-37695
    Kegel Leipzig Radio Sym Orch ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
    Keilberth Berlin Philharmonic 3/13,14/63 Teldec CD 8.43194 ............... 55:50 - 17:06 14:40 8:46 15:18
    better xfer than above -> Japanese Teldec CD WPCS-6052
    Telefunken LP GMA/SMA 83
    Telefunken LP SLT 43076
    Kubelik Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 1971 Originals CD 861 ............... 55:41 - 14:39 17:39 8:54 14:29
    Kubelik Chicago Symphony Orch live 12/82 CSO CD 92-2 ..................... 55:02 - 15:05 15:59 9:07 14:51
    Leitner Basel Sym Orch live 11/19/92 Accord CD 204 372 ............... 61:55 - 18:02 18:13 9:09 16:23
    Lopez-Cobos Cincinnati Sym Orch 2/3-4/91 Telarc CD 80264 ................. 56:44 - 16:00 17:52 8:21 14:14
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 7/88 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 03524/25/26
    Muti Berlin Philharmonic 1/88 EMI CD CDC 7494082 .............. 56:55 - 17:09 17:21 7:49 14:21
    Reichert Westfaelisches Sinfonie-Orch (c)1963 Vox LP STPL 512.540 ........... 58:58 - 16:53 16:18 9:41 16:06
    first few bars missing Classical Gold CD 082 ........... 59:20 - 16:52 16:14 9:45 16:05
    Turnabout LP 34226
    ZYX Classic CD CLS 4336 ..........59:02 - 16:51 16:14 9:43 16:03
    Rogner RSO Berlin (East) 6/19/80 Berlin Classics CD 309527 ....... 52:04 - 13:48 15:38 8:03 14:35
    Eterna CD 0030952BC
    Deutsche Schallplatten CD 32TC-52
    Sawallisch Bavarian State Orch 10/14/81 Orfeo CD C024821 A .............. 54:51 - 14:17 17:35 8:26 14:33
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch 3/3-4/97 Arte Nova CD 74321 54456-2 ... 56:53 - 15:39 18:36 8:43 13:53
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 6/79 London LP CS 7173 ............... 61:15 - 17:41 19:22 8:52 15:14
    London CD 417 389-2 & full set
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch live Unitel VHS (#?)
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Sym Orch 1984 Melodiya LP C10 23333000 .. 56:24 - 16:06 16:03 8:29 15:31
    JapanBMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38011/12.56:24 - 16:03 16:02 8:27 15:30
    Steinberg Boston Sym Orch 11/69 RCA LP Red Seal LSC-3177 ........ 52:15 - 14:53 16:15 8:02 13:05
    RCA LP 25009
    Swarowsky South German Philharmonic Highland Music LP
    Saar LP 1255
    Swarowsky Philharmonic Orch Bamberg (same as above) Joker LP 1255 .......... 50:45 - 13:09 15:36 8:06 13:50
    Swarowsky Vienna Festival Orch (same as above) Preludio CD 3145 ............ 50:45 - 13:09 15:36 8:06 13:50
    Vonk Residenzorchester der Haag (c)1994 Vanguard CD 990076 .............. 55:50 - 17:50 15:29 9:09 13:22
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 8/25/76 BMG/RCA CD 60081 & full set ..... 53:27 - 15:36 15:04 8:45 13:38
    EMI CDC 7 47747 2 & full set
    Harmonia Mundi LP 1C 065 99672
    Weiss Phil Vereinigung Wien (c)1978 Tuxedo CD 1094/5 ................ 50:45 - 13:10 15:31 8:04 13:51
    same as Swarowsky above
    Zsoltay Suddeutsch Philharmonie (c)1977 Saphir LP 25797 ................. 50:42 - 13:06 15:37 8:04 13:55
    same as Swarowsky above Mace LP 3609
    Intercord CD




    Symphony #6

    1899 version by Hynais[1899], pub Doblinger and Woss[1899].
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Adler Vienna Symphony Orch 2/17/52 Tahra CD 239-40 ................. 58:20 - 16:04 17:02 10:38 14:17




    Symphony #7

    1885 (aka 1883) alleged original version Ed. Haas[1944] (without percussion)
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Asahina New Japan Phil live 9/8/92 Fontec CD FOCD 9053/55 .......... 68:14 - 21:55 23:45 8:46 12:49
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 10/12/75 JVC CD VDC-1214 ................. 72:47 - 22:49 25:01 9:34 15:23
    live St.Florian
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic 4/14/76 Kobe Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 7/31/97 Kojima CD LMCD-1549 ............. 67:05 - 21:59 22:34 9:05 13:27
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 9/13/83 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set)
    JVC CD VDC 1067 or 511
    Asahina Osaka Philharmonic live 9/29/92 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00178 ....... 63:14 - 20:56 21:13 8:07 12:45
    Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00475
    Blomstedt Dresden Staatskapelle 7/3/80 Denon CD 38C37-7286 ............. 67:32 - 21:03 24:30 9:36 12:23
    Denon CD C37-7419
    Denon LP 7375/6
    Denon CD COCO-85054
    Deutsche Schallplatten CD 329 268
    Celibidache Berlin Philharmonic live 4/1/92 Sony VHS SHV48352
    Sony LaserDsk SLV48352
    Dumka CD-30-03/04
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic *1 live 10/18/90 Tokyo Sony VHS 48316-6 ...... 80:22 - 25:51 28:05 12:05 14:21
    Sony LD SLV48316
    Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 9/10/94 EMI CD 5566952 .................. 79:10 - 24:17 28:47 11:35 14:31
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym live 6/8/71 AS Disc CD 2505 ................. 66:54 - 21:08 23:52 9:47 12:00
    Liederhalle Arkadia CD GI 763.1
    mislabeled 10/26/71 Artists CD FED 011
    Andromeda ANR 2513
    DG CD 445 471-2 ................. 66:32 - 21:05 23:48 9:45 11:32
    Celibidache Stuttgart Radio Sym live Bells of St. Florian CD AB5
    d'Avalos Philharmonia Orch (c)1988 ASV CD 6154 ..................... 61:40 - 19:30 22:17 7:55 11:54
    ASV CD 625
    Haitink Royal Concertgebouw Orch 10/10/78 *1 Philips CD 446 580-2 ........ 65:08 - 20:51 22:21 9:51 12:05
    Philips CD 434 155
    Philips LP SAL 3785
    Philips LP 802 912 LY
    Philips CD 420 805-2
    Philips LP 6769 028
    Haitink Royal Concertgebouw Orch *1 Radio Nederland CD QDISC97014 ... 62:14 - 19:45 20:30 9:22 12:37
    live 10/14/72
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 6/6/69 *1 Arkadia CD 721 .................. 68:46 - 20:34 24:25 10:04 13:43
    London Hunt CD 721
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 2/4/71 *1 EMI CDM 7 69923 2 ............... 68:06 - 21:49 22:54 10:30 12:50
    EMI CDM 66095
    Angel LP SC-3779
    Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 4/75 *1 DG CD 419 195 ................... 64:32 - 20:08 22:04 9:52 12:28
    Musical Heritage Soc CD 514557A
    DG LP 2707 102
    DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set)
    DG LP 2740264 (full set)
    Karajan Vienna Philharmonic 4/89 *1 DG CD 429 226 ................... 66:15 - 19:47 23:12 10:10 12:42
    Karajan's last recording DG CD 439 037
    Karajan Vienna Philharmonic (c)1964 Radio Netherlands LP 109477/8 ... --:-- - --:-- 21:57 --:-- --:--
    Adagio only
    Konwitschny Leipzig Gewandhaus 6/20-22/58 Berlin Classsics CD 2114-2 ...... 65:21 - 20:39 21:32 10:15 12:43
    editing error on some copies-bar 204 of Scherzo missing 1st time
    Eurodisc 86 367 XHK
    Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 6/12/74 RCA CD 24207 .................... 65:00 - 19:55 21:55 10:00 13:10
    RCA CD 74321 30368-2
    Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set)
    Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 (full set)
    Eurodisc LP 27913XGK
    Denon CD COCO80100 full set
    Masur New York Philharmonic 9/13/91 Teldec CD 73243 ................. 63:28 - 20:04 21:00 9:35 12:22
    Teldec CD 3984-21338-2
    Teldec VHS
    Matacic Slovene Philharmonic 6/22/84 Denon CO-2035 ................... 65:46 - 20:04 22:00 10:42 13:00
    Noguchi Furtwangler Institute Phil Orch Tokyo CD WCD118 .................. 60:39 - 19:54 19:31 8:58 12:16
    live 1997 - some reorchestration by Noguchi (with cymbal crashes in Finale)
    Rogner RSO Berlin (East) 5-8/83 Berlin Classics CD 301620 ....... 59:15 - 18:52 18:50 9:16 12:02
    Eterna CD BC3016-2
    Rosbaud SW German RSO Baden-Baden 12/27,30/57 Vox CD CDX2 5518 ........... 63:09 - 19:01 21:31 10:44 11:40
    Vox LP SVBX 5117
    Vox LP VBX 117
    Vox LP 10.750
    Turnabout LP TV 340835
    ZYX Classics CD CLSR-4337
    Mediaphon CD 22.314
    Sinopoli Staatskapelle Dresden 9/91 *1,2,4,8,9 DG CD 435 786 ............... 64:57 - 19:46 22:51 9:35 12:45
    Tintner Royal Scottish National Orch 5/6-7/97 Naxos CD 8.554269 .......... 65:54 - 20:06 21:55 10:47 12:53
    von Otterloo Vienna Symphony 10/23-26/54 Philips LP A00249-50L ........... 65:00 - 18:00 25:00 10:00 12:00
    Epic LP CS 6006 ................. 64:00 - 18:07 24:46 9:42 11:05
    Walter Columbia Symphony Orch 3/11,13,19,22,27/61 Sony CD 64482 ......... 63:24 - 20:48 19:24 10:21 12:51
    Columbia LP M2S 690
    Columbia LP Y235238
    Sony CD MB2K 45669
    CBS Masterworks CD M2K 42036
    Wand Kolner Rundfunks Orch 1/18/80 BMG/RCA CD 60082 & full set ..... 64:50 - 19:57 22:38 9:45 12:02
    EMI CDC 7 47748 2 & full set
    Pro Arte LP 2PXL 2010
    Harmonia Mundi LP 153-99 877/78
    Wand NDR-Sinfonieorchester live 3/15-17/92 *9 RCA CD 09026 61398 ...... 63:31 - 19:28 21:49 10:00 12:14

    * see footnotes below in Nowak




    Symphony #7

    1885 version with some modifications by Bruckner under the influence
    of Schalk, Lowe, and Nikisch Ed. Gutmann[1885]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abendroth Berlin Radio Sym live 2/16-17/56 Tahra TAH CD 896 & 114/5 ........ 61:51 - 19:08 21:53 8:39 12:11
    this transfer is very sharp (in pitch)
    van Beinum Concertgebouw Orch 9/10/47 Decca 78s AK 1916-1923 .......... 59:57 - 19:26 20:15 8:32 11:23
    Tahra CD 252 .................... 59:46 - 19:33 20:24 8:38 11:21
    Dutton Labs CD K1205 ............ 59:36 - 19:26 20:15 8:32 11:23
    Music & Arts CD 1054(4) ......... 59:49
    van Beinum Concertgebouw Orch 5/53 Decca CD 421 139-2 .............. 58:40 - 18:40 19:05 9:10 11:45
    London LP LL 852/3
    UK Decca LP LXT 2830-229
    Japanese London CD POCL4589
    Decca CD 460 917-2
    Decca Eclipse LP ECS 571
    Bohm Vienna Philharmonic 6/4-5/43 Preiser CD 90192 ................ 67:17 - 18:58 27:30 10:01 10:48
    live without audience Vox LP XTV 15978-15981
    Vox LP PL 7190
    wrongly date 1948 -> Grammofono CD AB 78812/13 ....... 65:56 - 18:43 26:37 9:59 10:37
    Iron Needle CD .................. 65:56 - 18:43 26:37 9:59 10:37
    Fried Berlin State Opera Orch (c)1924 Bruno Walter Society LP BWS-719 . 58:15 - 17:11 20:55 8:38 11:40
    Polydor 78s 69753-59
    Polydor 78s 66318-24
    Discocorp LP
    Music & Arts LP 719
    Wing CD WCD 61
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic 2/2-4/41 Japanese AT LP 11-12
    missing Finale
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic 4/1/42 *1 Tahra CD FURT 1004/7 ............ --:-- - --:-- 22:50 --:-- --:--
    Adagio only LYS CD 106-107
    Music & Arts CD 954
    Teldec CD 9031764352
    Discocorp LP RR-457
    French Furt Soc LP SWF 8801/2/3
    Telefunken 78s SK 3230-3231 (original release)
    Akira Tanaka LP 11/12
    Ultraphon (Supraphon) 78s G22264-6
    Rococo LP 2014
    Japan JP LP 1101-1102
    French Furtwangler Society LP SWF 7702
    French Furtwangler Society CD SWF 963
    Istituto Discografico Italiano CD IDIS 293/94
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic 10/18/49 *1 Toshiba CD TOCE 8513 ............ 62:23 - 19:35 21:04 9:46 11:58
    mixed version by Furtwangler Toshiba CD CE28 5589
    Titania Palast Berlin Toshiba CD TOCE 6520
    Toshiba CD TOCE 3010
    EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2
    Dante Lys CD 214
    EMI LP SMVP 8055/56
    Electrola LP STE 91375-91378
    Angel (Japan) LP AA 9131-9132
    Angel (Japan) LP AA 8320-8321
    Pathe LP FALP 852-853
    EMI LP HQM 1169
    EMI LP 1C 147 29229-29230
    EMI LP F666.700
    Italian Urania CD URN 22.104
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic 4/23/51 *1,2,6,7 DG CD 445 418-2 .............. 62:37 - 19:02 22:01 9:41 11:39
    Cairo DG CD 445 415-2
    Music & Arts CD 894
    Theorema CD 121209
    DG LP 2721 202
    Japanese DG CD POCG-3796
    DG (Japan) CD POCG 2345
    DG (Japan) CD POCG 9498
    DG CD 3750
    DG LP 2740260
    DG LP 2535 161
    DG LP 2740 201
    Furtwangler Berlin Philharmonic live 5/1/51 *1,2,6,7 Arkadia CDWFE 362.1 ...... 63:19 - 19:56 21:33 9:39 11:56
    Rome Music & Arts CD 698
    Fonit Cetra LP FE 42
    Seven Seas CD KICC 2351
    Recital Records LP RR-416
    Rococo LP 2105
    Nippon Columbia LP OZ 7601
    Gielen Southwest German Radio Sym Orch 12/86 *5 Intercord CD 860.901 .... 58:10 - 17:59 19:28 9:28 11:15
    Intercord CD 830.864
    EMI CD 60105-2
    Hindemith New York Philharmonic live 2/28/60 Baton LP 1003
    mixed version - Gutmann mvt I, Haas mvt II
    Horenstein Berlin Philharmonic 1928 Koch Legacy CD 3-7022-2 ......... 58:35 - 17:33 21:42 9:28 10:32
    first electrical Bruckner recording -> Polydor 78s 66 802-2
    last 2 mvts pitched sharp -> Unicorn LP 111
    Brunswick 78s 90305-11
    Japanese DG CD POCG6071
    Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 3/28,30,31 & 4/1-2/52 Tahra CD 269 .......... 66:54 - 20:16 24:31 9:45 12:22
    American Decca LP DXE-146
    DG LP LPM 18033/4
    Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 10/10/64 *1,2,4,6,7,8 DG CD 445 010-2 ......... 67:56 - 20:34 24:56 9:41 12:32
    DG CD 429 079-2 (full set)
    DG CD 450 9026-2
    DG LP 2740-136 (full set)
    DG LP 139 137-38
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orch live 3/15/70 Tahra CD 168 & full set ......... 68:13 - 20:58 24:20 10:05 12:42
    Tahra CD 171/174
    Jochum Concertgebouw Orch 9/17/86 Bells of St.Florian CD AB15 ..... 75:43 - 22:49 27:56 11:20 13:15
    live - Jochum's last visit to Tokyo
    Jochum French National Orch live 2/6/80 Disques Montaigne CD 8770 ....... 69:56 - 20:28 25:35 10:12 13:21
    French INA memoire VIVE CD
    Jochum Vienna Philharmonic 5/8-9/39 Dante Lys CD 007/8 .............. 63:54 - 19:42 23:01 9:04 11:56
    Dante Lys CD 098 ................ 64:06 - 19:42 23:12 9:09 12:02
    Telefunken 78s SK 3000/7
    Capitol LP P8067-8
    Kabasta Munich Philharmonic live 9/24-27/42 Electrola CD 1C 053-28981 M . 58:18 - 17:05 21:46 8:25 10:47
    Preiser CD 90308
    EMI CD CHS5 66210-2 ............. 57:55 - 17:06 21:39 8:25 10:45
    MUCL CD 2007/8
    LYS CD 419-424
    Electrola 78s DB 7684-7691
    Knappertsbusch Cologne Radio Symphony Orch 5/5/63 Seven Seas LP K19C-18/9 ...... 67:33 - 20:29 20:16 12:03 14:45
    Knappertsbusch Vienna Philharmonic live 8/30/49 *1,6 Music & Arts CD 209 ......... 62:53 - 19:58 19:53 9:51 13:11
    Salzburg Festival Hunt CD 712
    Melodram CD GM40008 (set)
    Music & Arts CD 1028
    Reference Recordings LP 209
    Istituto Discografico Italiano CD IDIS 316
    Matacic Czech Philharmonic 1967 Supraphon CD 7419 ............... 68:54 - 21:30 24:00 10:36 12:48
    Supraphon LP SUA ST 50809/10
    Ormandy Minneapolis Symphony 1/5,7/35 Victor M-276 (78's) ............. 62:02 - 17:37 24:57 9:14 10:14
    Dante Lys CD LYS288
    Pesek Czech Philharmonic 11/11/86 Supraphon CD CO-72647 ........... 60:12 - 19:27 18:37 9:33 12:35
    Supraphon LP 11104981-82
    Rudolf Cincinnati Symphony 12/6/66 Decca USA LP DL-710139 .......... 55:12 - 17:02 18:11 8:29 11:30
    MCA/Westminster LP MCA-1412
    Schuricht Berlin Philharmonic 2/26,28 & 3/1 & 5/10/38 LYS CD 051 ........... 64:58 - 20:46 22:35 9:08 13:04
    Shinseido CD SGR-6006/7
    Polydor 78's PD-67195/202
    Iron Needle CD 1388
    Schuricht Hague Philharmonic 9/64 (misdated 1961) Originals CD 822 ......... 60:06 - 20:16 18:37 8:46 12:27
    Nonesuch LP H-71139
    Denon CD 30CO-1339
    Denon CD COCO 6591
    Denon LP 7259
    Preludio CD PHC 1126
    G.I.D. CD 1126 (Switzerland)
    Concert Hall LP SMSC 2394
    Schuricht Stuttgart Radio Sym Orch live 3/3/53 Disques Refrain CD DR920017 . 59:54 - 20:13 18:55 8:16 12:30
    Toscanini New York Philharmonic live 1/27/35 *1 Rodgers & Hammerstein ...... 57:16 - 18:06 20:15 8:52 9:27
    Archives at Lincoln Center
    cut and incomplete - the acetates were made with only one cutter
    Missing last 7 bars of mvt I and 4 bars before Y (Haas score) in mvt II




    Symphony #7

    1885 Eds. Gutmann[1885], Nowak[1954] (with percussion) or Haas[1944].
    Basically Nowak re-prints Haas edition, but puts the revisions of Schalk, Lowe, & Nikisch
    in brackets for conductors to note and choose from (Nowak feels that although the tempo
    and dynamic modifications are not in Bruckner's hand, he did sanction them).
    If those suggestions are ignored, there is little difference between Haas and Nowak versions.
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Abbado Vienna Philharmonic 3&4/92 *1,2 DG CD 437 518 ................... 64:22 - 20:17 21:57 9:17 12:51
    Albrecht Czech Philharmonic 2/26/95 Canyon Classics CD 00330 ........ 65:47 - 21:10 22:58 8:49 12:34
    Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic 2/92 *1,2,4,8,9 Teldec CD 9031-77118-2 ......... 70:41 - 21:55 24:54 10:24 13:29
    Barenboim Chicago Symphony Orch 3/79 *1,2,4,9 DGG LP 2707 116 ................ 66:36 - 20:34 22:57 10:28 12:37
    DG CD 429-025-2 (full set)
    DG CD 2GTA2 453100
    DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
    Bohm Vienna Philharmonic 9/29/76 *1,2,4,6,9 DG CD 419 858 .............. 65:58 - 19:30 23:59 10:29 12:00
    DG LP 2709-068
    DG Japan CD 3111-20
    DG France 463 550-2
    Chailly Berlin Radio Orch 6/84 *1,2 London/Decca CD 414290-2 ....... 69:08 - 22:46 22:48 9:58 13:21
    London/Decca CD 448710-2
    London/Decca LP 414 290-1
    London/Decca CD 466 574-2
    Davis Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 5/1/87 Orfeo CD 208891 .............. 67:55 - 21:18 23:59 10:23 12:15
    swaps order of Adagio & Scherzo III II
    Dohnanyi Cleveland Orchestra 8/90 *1,3 London/Decca CD 430 841 ........ 64:05 - 20:58 21:43 9:18 11:53
    Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 4/12/90 *1,2 Camerata CD 165 ................ 67:10 - 21:51 23:12 9:39 12:15
    Giulini Vienna Philharmonic 6/86 DG CD 449 305-2, 419627 ......... 67:52 - 20:22 24:08 10:35 12:31
    Italian DG Amadeus AM 071-2
    Haenchen Netherlands Philharmonic 9/27/91 Laserlight CD 14096 ............. 63:27 - 20:44 21:10 9:40 12:03
    Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 10/10/66 *1 Philips LP 802 759/60 AY & set .. 60:15 - 18:10 21:00 9:19 11:46
    not Haas as stated on recording Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)
    Philips LP PHS 2-998
    Harnoncourt Vienna Philharmonic 6/99 Teldec CD 3984 24488-2 .......... 60:00 - 19:10 20:48 8:53 11:09
    Nowak with no percussion
    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 9/10/85 Teldec CD 43259 ................. 63:28 - 19:24 23:31 9:39 10:54
    Teldec CD 420126
    Teldec CD 243147
    Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 12/14/76 *1,2,6 EMI CD CZS 5 68652 2 ........ 69:27 - 21:05 25:54 10:02 12:25
    EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set)
    Angel LP SZB-3892
    Klemperer Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 4/12/56 Hunt or Arkadia CD 708 ..... 58:45 - 18:05 19:36 9:09 12:35
    Klemperer Berlin Philharmonic 9/3/58 live *1 Frequenz CD 051-054 .......... 60:44 - 18:59 19:05 9:27 12:54
    Lucerne Music & Arts CD 751
    Frequenz Memoria CD CMD 1
    1st movement only -> Relief CD CR1883
    Klemperer Philharmonia Orch 11/5/60 *9 EMI CD 79885 (+ other stuff) .... 65:11 - 19:49 21:49 9:36 13:39
    Angel LP 35785/6
    Angel LP 3626B
    EMI CD CDM7 69126 (flat)
    Lopez-Cobos Cincinnati Sym Orch 1/22-23/89 *5 Telarc CD 80188 ................ 66:40 - 21:10 22:47 10:10 12:12
    Matacic Vienna Sym Orch 1979 Hypnos CD 257 ................... 63:27 - 19:18 21:38 9:35 12:30
    violins arco at end of mvt II
    Ormandy Philadelphia Orchestra 10/3/68 RCA LP LSC-3059 ................. 55:38 - 17:29 18:46 9:12 10:11
    Rattle City of Birmingham Sym Orch 9/96 EMI CD 7243-5 56425 ............. 70:58 - 22:48 24:09 10:35 13:23
    Skrowaczewski Saarbrucken Radio Sym Orch live 9/27,29/91 Arte Nova CD 777123 ... 68:45 - 21:45 24:46 9:33 11:45
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch live London Proms 1978 Decca VHS 071105-3DH ..... 73:48 - 22:03 24:14 10:31 16:30
    Unitel VHS (Japan) W6022 5010 (Polygram)
    Unitel LD 071-205-1 (DG)
    Solti Chicago Sym Orch 10/86 *1,2 London/Decca CD 417631 & set .... 68:36 - 21:27 25:12 10:10 11:45
    Decca CD (Solti Edition) 436615-2
    Solti Vienna Philharmonic 10/27/65 *1 London/Decca LP CSA-2216 ........ 65:10 - 20:42 22:46 9:34 12:08
    London/Decca LP 1326/38
    Decca Japan CD POCL-4576 ........ 65:22 - 20:45 22:49 9:37 12:13
    Decca CD 460 896-2
    Steinberg Pittsburgh Sym 4/68 MCA CD 99825 .................... 60:31 - 18:01 21:26 8:40 12:24
    Command Classics LP 12002
    Sine Qua Non LP SQN-7757
    Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 1/23-27/89 Berlin Classic CD ............... 63:11 - 18:53 21:15 10:18 12:34
    Deutsche Schallplatten CD 25TC297 63:11 - 18:53 21:15 10:18 12:34
    Deutsche Schallplatten Japan CD TKCC-15014
    Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 1980 Ars Vivendi CD 2100212 .......... 63:09 - 18:52 21:13 10:16 12:35
    same as above? wrong date?
    Szell Vienna Philharmonic live 8/21/68 Sony CD SMK 47646 ............... 63:57 - 20:32 21:14 9:29 12:39
    Rococo LP 2081
    Welser-Most London Philharmonic 8/27/91 EMI CD 54434 .................... 60:49 - 19:49 20:24 8:58 11:37


    *1 The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.

    *2 Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for
    one measure (waiting until the horns finish their melody, as in Haas)

    *3 Pure Nowak

    *4 Mixture of Haas & Nowak

    *5 Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the
    same place.

    *6 Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second
    statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the
    original printed score and Redlich's edition.

    *7 At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes
    from the 1885 edition or Nowak.

    *8 Rehearsal letter E (mm. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings
    at first (from Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba
    come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).

    *9 Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149). Only one
    trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet
    is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO
    recording, has the horns hold the note.)



    Symphony #7

    undetermined at this time


    Asahina Tokyo Sym Orch 4/23/94 Canyon Classics CD 362 .......... 69:02 - 22:21 22:09 9:38 14:52
    Bohm Bavarian Radio Sym Orch live 1970's Meteor CD-007
    Garben Berlin Philharmonic members 9/97 EMI CD 7243 55664229 ............ --:-- - --:-- 19:40 --:-- --:--
    2nd mvt only in a chamber arrangement by Bauer
    Guschlbauer Strasbourg Philharmonic 11/89 Erato 45492-2 ................... 66:24 - 20:10 23:15 10:04 12:36
    Hindemith Chicago Sym Orch live 4/7/63 CSO CD
    first mvt only VAI Video 69606
    Horn transcribed for organ by Horn Mitra LP 16180
    Adagio only
    Jochum Vienna Philharmonic live 6/9/74 Bells of St. Florian CD AB2 ..... 67:35 - 20:25 24:40 10:00 12:30
    Wiener Festwochen in the Musikvereinsaal
    Kegel Leipzig Radio Sym Orch ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
    Luisi Niederosterreichisches Tonkunstlerorchester live 4/6/98 ORF CD164. 71:16 - 21:58 26:17 9:27 12:47
    Maazel Berlin Philharmonic 2/88 EMI CD 49584 .................... 73:30 - 23:15 26:44 10:23 13:08
    Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Sym Orch 6/86 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 03159/60
    Mehta George Enescu Phil Orch 9/12/64 Electrecord LP 9
    Mills arranged for Organ by Marvin Mills Historic Organs of Baltimore
    Adagio only and cut Organ Historical Soc CD OHS-91 .. --:-- - --:-- 9:55 --:-- --:--
    Mravinsky USSR Symphony Orch live 2/25/67 Russian Disc CD 10 911 .......... 61:23 - 21:23 19:02 9:09 11:34
    ? Leipzig Gewandhaus Orch Eterna LP 8 27 453
    one movement (which one ?)
    Include in 200 Jahre Gewandhausorchester Leipzig (Historische Dokumente)
    Rozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture Sym Orch 1985 Melodiya LP C10 23763001 .. 64:04 - 19:52 21:09 10:32 12:31
    JapanBMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38011/12 64:21 - 19:49 21:06 10:30 12:33
    Sanderling Danish State Radio Sym Orch 1/14/77 Unicorn LP RHS 356 ........... 63:55 - 20:25 21:36 9:38 12:16
    Unicorn Cassette UKC 356
    Schmidt-Isserstedt North German Radio Sym Orch 10/28/68 Tahra CD 9901/2 ......... 59:40 - 18:34 20:25 9:20 11:02
    Tennstedt Chicago Sym Orch live CSO CD
    Vonk Residenzorchester der Haag Vanguard CD
    Wakagusi NHK Symphony Orch 1/96 BMC/RCA CD BVCC-750 ............. 65:06 - 19:55 22:01 9:36 13:01
    BMG CD 42824-2
    Watanabe Japan Philharmonic live 8/18-19/91 Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00118 ..... 59:40 - 18:10 18:35 9:30 13:25




    Symphony #8

    1887 Original version Ed. Nowak[1977]
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 8/82 Teldec CD 8.48218ZL ............. 75:35 - 14:01 13:25 26:46 21:08
    Teldec CD 8.44293
    Teldec CD 420225
    Teldec CD 243791
    Teldec LP 6.35642
    Tintner National Sym Orch of Ireland 9/23-25/96 Naxos CD 8.554215/6 ...... 89:28 - 17:41 15:14 31:10 25:10
    Tintner National Youth Orch of Canada 8/30/82 Jubal LP 5003-4 ............ 84:47 - 16:25 14:11 31:15 22:56




    Symphony #8

    c.1888 Adagio - unpublished
    Dave's Details - Jose's Details


    unrecorded
    Будьте счастливы!
    Zarastro.

  • Страница 1 из 56 1211 ... ПоследняяПоследняя

    Похожие темы

    1. Антон Брукнер целиком - Хайтинк или Шолти
      от Виталиус в разделе Симфоническая музыка / дирижеры
      Ответов: 55
      Последнее сообщение: 30.10.2009, 22:23
    2. Брукнер, симфони №9
      от Vaz21011 в разделе Композиторы / История музыки
      Ответов: 0
      Последнее сообщение: 29.03.2008, 20:44
    3. Гитлер, Вагнер, Брукнер...
      от regards в разделе Про все на свете
      Ответов: 32
      Последнее сообщение: 09.02.2008, 08:25
    4. Брукнер и Малер
      от sforzando в разделе Симфоническая музыка / дирижеры
      Ответов: 224
      Последнее сообщение: 15.01.2008, 21:20
    5. Антон Брукнер. Месса?
      от domine в разделе Аудио- и видеозаписи
      Ответов: 6
      Последнее сообщение: 23.10.2006, 09:15

    Метки этой темы

    Социальные закладки

    Социальные закладки

    Ваши права

    • Вы не можете создавать новые темы
    • Вы не можете отвечать в темах
    • Вы не можете прикреплять вложения
    • Вы не можете редактировать свои сообщения
    •  
    Яндекс.Метрика Rambler's Top100